8.3 to the mashed potato slice
domenick.scali1/10/21, 8:39 p.m.
Good crisp, undercarriage could have been cooked a touch more. Good sauce. Juicy first bite.
brandon.depinto12/28/20, 6:04 a.m.
Tomato Pie. Perfect thin and great sauce. Great beer!!!
7 views•0 likes
adam.sciorsci12/11/20, 10:58 p.m.
There's a lot of hype around the old school pizza joints in New Haven, and you have to give them respect, but BAR is just turning out a superior pie. We hit Sally's, Pepe's, Modern, and BAR (all same day, in that order) and BAR just had the best tasting, crispiest, most consistent pizza. It wasn't even really close, and we were expecting this to kind of be the afterthought of the day - wrong. It's genuinely a great pizza.
connor.giudice11/21/20, 3:34 a.m.
I was very impressed with this pizza. Didn’t expect much after watching Dave’s review but I was blown away at how fantastic this is. Paper thin, great cheese, amazing pizza
b.mac211/21/20, 2:25 a.m.
I was shocked at the quality of this pie! I completely disagree with Dave’s score, this za was fantastic. It was paper thin, similar to inferno. The sauce had a fresh bright flavor. The cheese was quality, the crust was thin and crunchy. The za had major flop. I would take this over modern
ecao10/25/20, 9:10 p.m.
Cheese pizza: good cheese; good sauce; good dough; a bit too dry all around; the gas smell/taste wasn’t particularly pleasant; could be more crispy/crunchy; a bit more greasy than I would like; could be more burnt
michael.cocosis10/10/20, 11:15 p.m.
This one did it, and I was expecting a low score. Bar broke into the 9s. This couldn't be cooked better. Cheese was great, sauce was great, just a little light on both. This was cracker thin crust. Every bite was amazing. We killed this pizza in under 5 mins. Best part about this bad boy was the cheese... You know that burnt cheese flavor you love? It was basically the whole pizza. Under crust, perfect. Outer crust, even better. Absolutely BANGIN'.
christine.hammett10/10/20, 11:09 p.m.
Wow! This was such a good pizza! Great sauce, cheese, and crust. No flop at all and great flavor. Also amazing service and the BAR salad was incredible.
dan.montani9/17/20, 6:23 p.m.
Honestly almost as good as pepes or sallys and usually far less of a wait. Pres gave a rookie 7.4 grow up
justinsilver9/6/20, 7:34 p.m.
Thankfully one of the New Haven spots saved the day! Bar Pizza was phenomenal. Crust: perfect. Sauce to cheese ratio: on point. Tad bit or flop and a little oily knock it below a 9, but overall, would definitely make this my spot for a pizza night out! From the GF, on the buff chick: she liked the touch of oregano. Liked the buffalo sauce, but not overpowering. Service was solid.