Barnaby's - Mishawaka

Tastes like chef boyardee crust. Sauce taste like it’s from a can.

Good local pizza, crust is crunchy and toppings are good. Cheese is okay and full along with toppings. Sauce is not tangy little more neutral. Good pizza if you are in the area

I was expecting more…not bad but being from Chicago this gets talked about quite a bit. Maybe it’s a ND thing?

Pizza was surprisingly good! Got the traditional Pep, Sausage crust had a nice crisp and sauce was legit. Only negative was the cornmeal crust if thats your bag then it would be in the 8's.

Great pizza 🍕

Tasty ass pizza. I could easily eat a whole pie in one sitting. The one downside is that it’s greasy. Great pizza for cold leftovers.

It was okay, will finish.

One of the 2 local favs (other being Rocco's) I am not a fan of this place. Very light sauce makes it kinda dry. Cheese is ok Pepperoni is good Dough is alright Mushrooms (canned) not a fan. Round pizza cut in squares.

Definitely a unique pizza overall. I would have preferred a little more sauce, that’s about my only complaint. Sauce trends to the spicy side but it’s very good. Crust was good but some my not like the corn meal on the bottom, I like it though. Cheese was plentiful and good. One of the better pizzas in this area.

Meh

Barnaby's is a Notre Dame area tradition.. the pizza has a sturdy crust, good thick toppings and a sauce with a bit of a bite... definitely worth the stop!

Lots of cheese, soft crust, 0 flop

One of the best pizzas in Mishawaka/South Bend