dan_dan_the_pizza_man2/22/23, 10:18 p.m.
What an amazing place. I loved everything about!! The location, the building, the inside, the decor, how you order. Everything was so throwback and a classic old school pizza joint. The pizza is tavern style and pretty good. This is not my favorite style and I am not real big on cornmeal crust. However, for this style pizza it was really good. This is a must try location not only for the pizza but to enjoy the atmosphere.
eatinsomeza2/9/23, 8:41 p.m.
Very good! The sauce and the cheese are phenomenal. The crust isn’t my style but I liked it very much.
mikey.mercaviews10/24/22, 6:48 p.m.
Unique cornmeal dusted dough and crispy wavy crust. Undercarriage is as thin as can be but is still sturdy with no flop. Solid combination of meat, sauce, and cheese.
jryn0019/16/22, 2:08 a.m.
Dave was too generous with a 7.8. This is closer to a 6.0 for folks from the northeast who know good pizza. This might be great in Chicago but not New Haven, CT.
gio.lucchetto7/11/22, 5:57 a.m.
Pretty good pizza. Light on the sauce was the down fall. Has a lot of crisp with the interesting corn crust they have. The cheese is very good as well. I’m going 7.8, not bad at all definitely worth a drive.
steven.harry4/1/22, 11:17 p.m.
Excellent way to end boys day. Perfect crust, nice sauce, & great cheese. Absolutely love it.
dylan_matthew1/2/22, 8:06 p.m.
Crust wasn’t bad. The sauce had a good tang and the cheese was real good, I’d definitely come again…
anthony.vizek12/29/21, 11:30 p.m.
Real flavorful sausage. Dough reminds me a little of Home Run Inn but better. Super thin but it holds the toppings well. The crimped crust gave it a nice crunch that I really liked. Just outside of the top tier of Tavern Styles for me.
vinny.bagodonitz12/10/21, 5:37 a.m.
I’d rather eat a Tombstone. Barnaby’s is cheese and ketchup on a cornmeal Triscuit. Barely worthy of a review.
kjw78009/29/21, 12:15 a.m.
Dave hit this motha' right on the spot. Around that high 7 range. A good above average pizza but nothing too special. The under carage is the best part. Im more of a thick crust guy but this was decent.
joey.g77/14/21, 11:11 p.m.
Not quite the Barnaby‘s in Rogers Park that I grew up on, but pretty damn close. Outstanding taste and crust. Cornmeal on the bottom. Maybe not for everybody, but it’s definitely for me!
brad.kamps16/19/21, 12:55 a.m.
Good crsip! Corn meal crust is unique. Could use just a bit more sauce!
drew.heitzman5/30/21, 10:26 p.m.
Ate last week so no pic. With that said this is the best thin crust pizza in the state of Illinois.
tom.c65/10/21, 12:25 a.m.
Cool spot but the crust is very different. It is ok just not my taste.