Not too flavorful, crust had a burnt metal taste from the oven. thin and crispy...very basic. Dave dropped the ball here
Order now on Slice
Order Basile's Pizza
Hungry? Order right now on Slice
hector.salamanca11/6/22, 11:27 p.m.
Got hungry on the way home… seriously great slice. Thin, crispy. Crust, cheese, and sauce all top notch.
bigphat10/20/22, 4:38 a.m.
Cheese is terrific (esp the ricotta). Toppings and sauce above average at minimum, but holy shit this crust knocks it out of the park for a by-the-slice spot. Slices are deceivingly full and even if you’re not a crust person the char and crunch from the crust is amazing. Had high expectations going in and I would say they were exceeded.
erik.wachter9/27/22, 8:08 p.m.
This is a great plain slice. I’m not really ranking anything above a 9 until I come across something that really knocks my socks off. Until then I giving at 9s for top notch slices. I gave it a slight 0.1 ding because I would have liked it a bit more well done, but it was a single re-heated slice so that’s understandable. The cheese is great, the sauce is fresh and the bottom crust has a nice crunch that is unique to Basile’s pies. I recently visited Portnoys #2 spot, based on his ratings, DeLucias in Raritan Nj. Dave gave them a 9.4 and gave Basile's a 8.1. Basiles blows DeLucias slice out of the water!
eric.neuls8/17/22, 6:24 p.m.
Oh my God, thin, crispy, slightly tangy sauce. Everything you want in a pizza! Must come here and get this!
pizzaking3135/16/22, 9:45 p.m.
Perfect undercarriage, I got a fresh slice so it def boosts the ratings. Solid flavor and crust
joetheumpire4/30/22, 9:40 p.m.
After checking the reviews we had to make a stop. Pizza was very crispy and thin. Great flavor. A little greasy. But still great.
km0113/17/22, 11:27 a.m.
I'm not sure what it is with the name, but this place puts artichoke Basile's to absolute shame. Basile's is located on a busy corner and head all of their doors wide open when I went there so you could just walk right in, mind you and this was in the middle of winter! LOL Lots of foot traffic and not necessarily of the best kind, as a panhandler actually asked me for money inside this location to buy a slice of pizza. Since I assumed that wasn't what he actually wanted the money for I told him I couldn't help him, he then went and asked the guy behind me in line. To my surprise the guy working there actually gave him a slice to get him out of everyone's faces, and then told him to have a nice day, which was pretty much a nice way of saying get the hell out of here! Lol! If this isn't a New York slice, then nothing is! Absolutely zero flop and tons of crunch. I can see why lots of people are in the eights on this, but if they want a friendly reminder to what an eight truly tastes like they should take a trip to 10th Street Pizza, as it's clearly Superior to this product.
adam.wood22/25/22, 7:36 p.m.
Crunch is awesome, sausage pretty good, cheese just right. Sauce kinda light, could use more.
farpieog1/25/22, 5:56 p.m.
I dont know what people are looking for in Pizza if you dont like this place. I think it was literally one of the most classic NY slices I have had in years.. Thin and crispy but still had chew and not over cheesed sauce and everything worked so well together. This is one of my favorite classic NY slices I have ever eaten and cant wait to go back!!
mohammod.arafat1/6/22, 2:32 a.m.
Surprised it was scored so high. The cheese pizza was light one cheese, light on sauce, and light on flavor.