stefano.papoutsakis4/24/21, 4:54 p.m.
This pizza has been around for 43 years, I grew up on it while living in Brooklyn for the majority of my life!!! There are several amazing Brooklyn pizzerias which I also plan on visiting while back in town...but this place is always the first place I eat from!! The flavor has remained the same for as long as I’ve been eating here!! The sauce is what does it for me!! The 8.8 is not just for the Sicilian pie, it’s for their pizza in general!! I love the traditional round as well, but in general I lean towards Sicilian because I love a good deep crust!!! If you haven’t tried them before, it’s a must!!!
1 view•0 likes
pizzasherpa221/18/20, 11:02 p.m.
Voted Best Pizza in Bkln??? Too doughy and cheesy in my opinion. Sauce has good tang.
pizzapaarty7/20/19, 12:46 a.m.
Very solid slice, nice crisp, tangy sauce... slightly heavy on the cheese but very high quality ingredients
matthew.morgan15/21/19, 1:32 a.m.
Work in Bay Ridge and I have to say Bay Ridge Pizza has one of the top tier slices in the neighborhood. The sauce I believe is really their specialty. Grandma slice is their forte, but you’re not gonna be disappointed with just a regular pie. Definitely a football pie.
smahoney905/9/19, 6:29 p.m.
So far, one of, if not the best grandma slice I've come across. Nice crispy crust, with a delicious semi-sweet sauce with a hint of fresh basil.