Bay Village Pizza

Great pizza

Very typical shore town slice. Had a decent amount out crisp and felt pretty good in your hands

Great pizza good crust nice flavor I’d come back for it for sure if I’m in the area.

Light and crispy but that’s most likely because it was reheated. Other than that the flavor is nothing to write home about. Don’t think it’s worth $4 a slice, but still pretty decent

Top 3 on the island but that’s not saying much

Big slice, the sauce and crust were good, overall nothing to write home about

Average slice

Updated score

Decent pizza. Cooked well.

Great flavor, not greasy great crust. Would like a tad more crisp but this is an excellent slice. Best in Beach Haven, possibly best on LBI.

Low grade football pizza. No flop, but no crisp. Good on the go, hangover greasy pizza

I have had it better before. Could be coronavirus related why it’s bad. I’ve seen reviews on this saying that it’s the best pizza on the island but not close to a Slice of Heaven. Mediocre pizza

Was very above average! I recommend it!

Good stuff

It has only 2 of the 4 core shore slice components (size and thinness), but it is missing the 2 most critical: oil and flop. Indeed, after a day shredding gnarular waves (combo of gnarly and tubular) at the beach, one usually yearns for a flacid, oily shore slice. This slice fails in this department but overall is an averagish slice. Cowabunga!

Probably the best pizza on the island, but that’s not saying much. On the floppier & greasy side. Better options at the other shore points.

No flop, no grease, great crisp, tang to the sauce