Bay Village/Schooners Wharf

Decent pizza and one of the better ones at LBI. Not super crispy but has a good taste. Always try to have pizza from here when I visit LBI.

Honestly this pizza is stunning. A perfect boardwalk like pizza with a perfect crisp when I bite into it. The pizza is authentic and the best in LBI for sure

This in my opinion is probably the best pizza on the island. You gotta try it if you visit LBI

Good boardwalk style

decent slice. minimal flop but pretty bland.

Big slice, could use a little more crisp on the undercarriage

Three pies. 88 bucks. Pre made and tipped to order. Doughy crust with flop that even an OD of Pizza Viagra could not cure. Bland sauce. Premium add on cost for each mediocre topping. Does not even qualify as drunk pizza.

Bad picture. Solid football pizza slice

Cheese was the best part

Best traditional style pizza on the island. Love the cheese - that’s what separates this from the other places around here.

Perfect amount of crispness. Good cheese, good tomato sauce sweetness.

Pretty good piZza.. good sauce

The only thing this pizza had going for it was a crispy crust. Sauce was funky, cheese was cheap and greasy. Had ageda on the ride home to Brooklyn.

Beat pizza on island

Decent beach pizza, perfect fold. Get with the cheese fries.

Better than I remembered