Beekman Ale House

Probably the best bar pie I have had, if not it is close. I can’t rank it higher than an 8.1 because bar pizza isn’t my favorite style.

Couldn’t tell the difference between the cheese and the hot oil. Very good but seemed like a Colony Grill wannabe…

Hot oil and pepperoni

Good light bar pie. French onion specialty slice was better than cheese.

While up in Sleepy Hallow, we had to stop at Beekman Ale House and they did not disappoint. Bar pie style. The cheese had a zing in the sauce with a very crispy crust. While you’re there, give the hot oil pizza and the Hot Honey a try as well. Interesting take on a Hot Honey pizza which was the unanimous favorite.

It was alright.

Good for bar pizza. VERY crispy. I enjoyed it but not something on my mind I NEED to get again. A little flavorless, but overall a good bar pizza

Too greasy, but a good thin bar pie - would’ve preferred more well done

Beekman ale house never misses especially with their pizzas of the week. Their cheese pizza and hot oil pizza are great. Sauce tastes amazing, always super crispy, and bubbly undercarriage makes it one of my favorites.

Not to shabby. But a little shabby #kyle

Classic Bar Pie, thin crust, cheese and sauce have great flavor. Totally delicious this is a must try place with a super cool vibe. Definitely stop by when in the Tarrytown/Sleepy Hollow area!

Great bar pie, hot oil gives a nice kick. Would like a touch more sauce, but great pie.

Tried the BBQ chicken and the pepperoni but added hot honey to the pepperoni. Delicious

Just ok could have been cooked longer not in the class of Kinchleys,Vic’s or Federicis

Bar style pie, very thin but not too crispy. Lacked a little sauce as it was slightly dry, despite the cheese being flavorful. Solid pie overall, crush some awesome craft beer while you are here.

Classic bar pizza. Great flavor, great sauce & cheese!

BBQ chicken pizza. Not bad. Very flavorful.

Flavor was just mediocre

-Oily/greasy -Thin without being crispy -had a bit of zing, like there were peppers or hot oil or something -crust was delightful -tasted like they tried to make a south shore bar pizza based on a description but never tried it themselves. Overall, pretty good pie and decent bar. Good local spot.

Stopped here on our way back from New Haven CT to Cobourg ON. Pizza was great…wish we had pizza of this caliber in our town but sadly we do not. Found out about the place from the one bite review on YouTube.

Pretty solid bar pie. Great crust and ingredients.