🍺LEGENDARY BAR PIE ALERT🍺 💎HIDDEN GEM ALERT💎 😴 SUPER SLEEPER ALERT😴 Call your friends, wake the neighbors, alert the media…this is HALL OF FAME bar pie, first ballot, the stuff legends are made of. They call it thin crust, even though its a pan pizza with no actual crust. It’s a cross between Detroit style with the scrumptiously charred edges and Chicago style cause it’s circular, but in bar pie fashion, not deep dish. Each pie is about 12 inches, personal size, but also shareable and simply sublime. The dough is thin, crispy, no flop, not too well done, just enough char, cooked to perfection. Phenomenal flavor overall…one of the most delicious pizzas I’ve ever eaten. This pie is a feast for the senses, particularly smell & taste. There’s a garlic flavor that permeates from the sauce and seasoning that creates a taste explosion combined with the spice & tang, tremendous pizzazz and kick. The cheese is super tight, razor thin, with a smokey flavor and light layer of oil that locks in the sharp taste to go along with a perfect ratio to the amount of sauce & dough. If you love bar pies, this is absolutely worth a pilgrimage; they don’t get much better than this. The bar itself is a really quaint tavern that plays up the whole Headless Horseman/Sleepy Hollow theme. Very cool scene…I felt like Brom Bones was gonna walk in and throw back a mug of ale. The town is actually celebrating the bicentennial of the legend this Fall. Portnoy has to get here and see where this ranks among all-time bar pies. This is Hall of Fame worthy, must-try pizza. Get here before the word gets out and it goes from hidden gem to legendary status. 🏆
Order now on Slice
Order Beekman Ale House
Hungry? Order right now on Slice
ryan.colella2/20/23, 6:33 p.m.
Colony’s fav cousin. Thin bar pie. Freddy Krueger broil cheese. Easy pie to the gullet. Under carriage could use a little extra attention to crisp if I were to shine on a complaint
ryanallday12/17/22, 7:02 p.m.
Easily in the 8’s. Dave’s review looks like that shit sat for an hour before he got it. This pizza is amazing.
stooliepizzaguy9/5/22, 2:01 a.m.
If you like ultra thin bar pie - this is your spot. I personally don’t love this style, I need more bread. This is like cracker pizza. Great taste though, very friendly server, cool ambience and easy on the stomach!
colin.ford7/18/22, 7:24 p.m.
A little less sauce and it would have scored better, still delicious
anthony.leggiero15/28/22, 11:06 p.m.
Excellent pie. Very crispy with a nice crunch. Very friendly wait staff. Been here a few times already and this place never disappoints.
michaelmo3/23/22, 11:14 p.m.
Great bar pizza! Back end of each slice is kinda sublime with the thin crunch and char. One of the only pizza in westchester not football so this is a gem.
bite.mi1/30/22, 11:40 p.m.
Beekman Ale House, this is a special bar pie. That lip crust and tang sauce tickles the taste buds. Definitely a must stop.
pegirl12312/23/21, 11:41 p.m.
Great place! But the pizza was alright. Awesome atmosphere to come and chill.
daveturner10/23/21, 11:33 p.m.
Bar style pizza, a little on the greasy side (oils from cheese??) Good flavor overall, a solid bar pie! Crust on the softer side too, unlike other bar pies (where the consistency is more like a cracker) But after a day of hiking ‘breakneck ridge trail’, this was probably the best pizza within 40 minute proximity.
justin.turner10/23/21, 11:31 p.m.
The home of the headless horseman has a hidden gem of a pizza place. Very good bar pie. Thin and crispy. Cooked near perfection. Good sauce and cheese ratio. A little bit more grease than you would want, but it adds to the flavor. Portnoy should visit here. Totally up his alley.
stevepizzareviews10/11/21, 1:41 a.m.
Good bar pie, thin and crispy. Dough used needs a bit more flavor and is masked by a charred (somewhat burnt) oven taste. Sauce and cheese quality is average. Will say this place is awesome, and a great pie to enjoy over some beers and football.