Bella Pizzeria - Carmel

Good flavor, doesn’t fall apart, but is a bit floppy for me- even asking for it to be left in the oven a little longer for more crisp. Great place that’s close by for a good slice!

Great taste, good crunch. Wish it was a little easier to bite off.

Great crunch, and great flavor, a little to floppy for my liking at the end.

Great Crunch. One of the better pizza’s I’ve had for sure.

Crisp bottom, classic Ny slice. Folds well and the sauce and cheese flavor is on top. Solid pizza

Pretty good

Thin New York style crust that has a little crisp on the bottom, nothing crazy about the sauce, plenty of cheese that creates a nice cheese pull with each bite, pepperonis are kinda thin and flimsy

Thin New York style crust that has a little crisp on the bottom, nothing crazy about the sauce, plenty of cheese that creates a nice cheese pull with each bite, pepperonis are kinda thin and flimsy

Love that you can get it by the slice. Really crispy crust.

In two words: cold and greasy. I looked at their website, and it said online orders were closing in 13 minutes. I quickly placed an order (14” pepperoni), and it said my pizza would be ready at 8:10pm. I didn’t have anything to do, so I went ahead and drove to the store. I parked outside the pizza shop, and could see everything through the front window. I was about 25 minutes early, and their order tracker said they were prepping my order. A short time later it said my order was being made. I waited in my car, watching them mop and clean up through the window. (It was close to closing time.) The tracker still said my food was being made, but I didn’t see any pizzas going into the oven. I went inside at 8pm (10 minutes early) while the order tracker STILL said my order was being made... but my pizza was sitting on top of the oven! It had to be up there the entire time I waited, because I never saw them take a pizza out of the oven. The pizza that I picked up 10 minutes early and the tracker said was being made was ALREADY COLD. I took my cold pizza home. The sauce wasn’t very good, the pepperoni was filled with grease, and it was just a bland, nasty meal.

i swear bella changed their pizza recipe in the last few years. used to be absolutely perfect, but now it’s just not the same. it’s still really good, but just not as good as it was in 2015. the sauce isn’t as chunky and tangy as it used to be, it seems like they started getting different sauce, they put way more cheese on than they used to, and now it’s way more floppy and greasy.

The regular is bette the white! The white pizza is a little dry

Marginally better than Sbarro

Not many places where you can get a slice in this town, so they get a bonus point.

Classic New York style pizza

Nice thin crust. Some flop, not greasy. For Indiana, you could probably bump it up a point!