Bellagio Pizzeria & Restaurant

Finally we made a Long Island pizza review on 2024, and that will make it for our second pizza review in Nassau County. I actually never had Farmingdale pizza before. Even though the slices are solid and the crust is crispy, but it’s not the best though. Because it’s a little greasy, still has a good taste though. Grandma Slice: 8.1 Michael’s rating: 8.0 Grandma Slice: 8.2

Normal pizza

Deep dish is 7.6

Football pizza

Come on Bellagio , ordered a mushroom slice and this is what I get? An old regular slice and u threw some mushrooms on top? Just say you don’t have any mushroom. Disappointed

Great crust

Got a white slice and and tomato. They listened to Dave since the undercarriage was crispy. But it wasn’t anything spectacular.

Delicious Buffalo chicken and a crispy yet not too thick crust for both a Buffalo and a regular slice. Very good. We came to a score of 8.2 -splitting the difference from the 7.4 on the regular slice and the 8.7 of the Buffalo slice.

Overall good slice. $3.85 cash for a regular slice is pretty steep though. Crispy underside with good sauce to cheese ratio. Definitely can taste the onion/garlic in the sauce.

Crust was lite. Slice was a little greasy. Sauce was too bland for me.

Great slice! Great crunch. Little flop. Good undercarriage. Wish they didn’t use canned mushroom tho. Always go fresh.

Good sauce good cheese. Little crispier and it would be better

Great crisp on the crust, pretty good pizza, just a little too much cheese, it overwhelms the sauce.

Wocky

Ok, the pizza is great, the sauce & cheese where perfect however the crust and bread so hard to chew, it’s took forever, then I notice the bottom was burnt. So it’s tough to score cause of on mistake, if it wasent burnt it would be a easy 7.5

The challenge with this place is the completion close by. villa monte is much better. Victors also rivals it. It's hard for me to judge it without thinking about that. Lot of options though for sure. Pizza is decent .

Nothing particularly great about it. But nothing particularly terrible either.

I’ve tried this place years ago, never scored it. Crust was a little too crunchy, sauce has a distinct flavor. It’s good… it seems to be close to really good….

Slice is average, sauce doesn’t have much taste nor the cheese. Crust was a bit soft for my liking.

It was pretty good. Nothing special but nothing bad by any means. The place ha s a really greta tmosphere too for anyone who is affected by that.