Bennie's Bread & Italian Market

Solid pizza, plain was better than margarita. Really nice place too

Alert- no time time for long review Regular plain pie- excellent, a tad soft in middle but great end crust and beautiful taste 8.3 Bonus veggie- delicious 8.2 Tomato pie - intense tang no sweet awesome crunch 8.1 Margherita- again terrific and excellent execution 8.2 Travel worthy. Lives up to hype. Truly terrific Marvin Haller said, “Championships are won before you get in the ring.” This place absolutely gets it. Fantastic!

Great under carriage. Great crunch. Really good pie. Best pizza on the island.

Margherita style! It comes in one size, but a solo person could finish it off quite easily. Very light crust. Sauce is sweet (believe they use the same sauce from their known tomato pie). Solid ingredients.

I’ll call this “baker” pie style, very fresh margarita style pizza. Sauce was very sweet with a hint of garlic and basil flavors. On the small size (one size) for big pizza eaters.

The crust and sauce were very good. The sauce had a great flavor and the crust had a great crunch. The cheese was decent and added to it but could have been better. Overall i could have eaten more than a pie of this pizza it was very good

Crust is good but wasn’t a good crisp everything else about the pizza was good

Simply based on the tomato pie. Sauce was very tangy and zesty. Surprised the heck out of me.

Really solid Margarita pie. Great flavor and texture in the crust. Fresh tasting sauce. Might be the best in OCNJ. Their sausage pizza may have even been better.

Good crisp. No flop. Cheese is good. Sauce is missing something. Solid slice in OC.

Waited a bit to think over my score since I knew it would be a very high one. Place deserves it, pizza is nuts. Tomato pie is a trip if you go you should try it. Regular food is also unreal had a meatball parm fucking awesome.

From the crust to the flavors coming off this great slice. Bomb

Famous tomato pie. Lightest tomato pie your ever have. Great chunky sauce. Overall excellent