Benny Capitale's

Gets better as you keep eating. NOT just a drunk pizza

Gas pack. Ratios are right. Fast service. Crispy. More than solid 7.4.

One bite. Crispy every bite. $4 even. Crust is crazy good.

I know, I know,.....rookie score. I think the reviews in the 6-7 range are off. This pizza is way better than just decent local neighborhood pizza. I use Bennys as my standard if I'm deciding between a 7.9 and an 8.1, thus Bennys is the generic rookie score of 8.0. It's not just giant gimmick pizza. This pizza is the real deal; super thin, super crisp, and not greasy. Love Bennys. Pizza.

Could’ve been higher if the sauce wasn’t so tangy, crunch was on point tho, great dark brown undercarriage. Probably a great drunk pizza.

Crazy size, no flop, great crunch, good cheese to sauce ratio, sauce needs work, quality slice for $4

Drunk pizza

Great crunch minimal flop for a pizza this size and great taste

If you stumbled in here at 2am after a night of keystone lights on the beer pong table it’s a 9+. Unfortunately that wasn’t the case today. Love the size. Body of the dough has a nice crisp but it just gets so damn doughy. Sauce above average. Cheese a little burnt. All that being said, it’s pretty ok.

Very hot pie. Very large. Good pie. Great crunch. Good pull in crust. Lack of flavor in the cheese. Pockets of sauce are great tasting. The char is a tad overwhelming and takes from the pie.

The best thing about the slice is the size, these guys get what pizza in that sense. Fresh enough and not too greasy. Place is probably 5* by Carolina standards. They don’t serve anything else, but it’s a pizza place why are you asking for anything else?

After 1am - worth every penny

Huge slices

Great cheese, good sauce, little flop. Mild crunch. Good late night slice. Huge portion $5

Great pizza! Good ratio of cheese to marinara. Cooked well.

Surprising crisp. Great sauce. Giant slice. Solid pizza

Slices as big as your face. Little over-cooked, but overall really good! Would come back.

Was a little overcooked but great potential

Very good for big pizza. When fresh, it competes.