Benny Fierro's

Impressed. Thought this would be a big slice novelty spot. Thin crust. Crispy outside, but doughy. Nice cheese blend (very sharp). Savory sauce. Well balanced. Eat it hot. Loses a lot once it cools down, but does reheat well.

Crispy bottom, excellent cheese, huge slice

Not enough cheese this time and the slices were really hard. The ranch is good though and this place is clutch so it deserves a 7.1.

Late night intoxicated pizza. The large slices are to fool you of the low quality cheese they use. Can’t even really taste the sauce. There’s a reason they don’t proudly display the generous 6.4 rating Dave gave them.

Biggest pizza ever!!! Also one of my favorites. Don’t let the size fool you, this is great pizza!!! Nice sauce and cheese ratio and no too greasy

Not enough sauce

Big slice, reminds me of jersey shore pizza

I ordered 2 slices, one Ain and one pepperoni. Enormous slices make me wish I had ordered one. Generally hate giant slices, but this was better than most. Slice #1. No flop. Crisp undercarriage. Crust is chewy and crisp. Nothing remarkable about the sauce but definitely not bad at all. Good cheese. Slice #2. Way, way thinner and way more crisp. So think that it tore across the center the moment I first held it. Flop City. Super flop. More greasy. Inconsistency was the problem and what kept my score from being higher.

My favorite slice in Pittsburgh nice crisp throughout huge one slice is all ya need

HUGE slice if you don't buy a whole pizza! Very tasty

Good, massive pizza. It’s a “drunk pizza,” one of those ones where you’re hammered and it tastes awesome.

Great taste, huge slice. Quite a bit of grease but has a nice crisp to it.

Thin, crispy, great taste. Still my favorite pizza, must try!

I wanted it well done. They did not disappoint. Absolutely no flop, good cheese, no greese. Slices are huge. Definitely Worth giving a try!

Good crust and overall good taste

NY flop

Big G’s inaugural review post Pitt game