Benny Marzano's

Nice crispy pizza. Very hot. Huge Slice. The mothership of all Benny’s!!!

College pizza in a nutshell, does the job but nothing special. Super parmy.

Hot sauce + parm + oregano + chilly flakes. Best combo.

No flop, solid crust, not getting a lot of cheese flavor

Great pizza

This is a typical college dive joint with good pizza. Students smash slices after late nights of partying. I was visiting a friend and I tried a couple of slices. I took several bites, even though I knew the rules… oversized slice and extremely filling! Sauce is good, crust is crispy but I’m sticking with a 6.8. Ambience gives a must try if your in the area.

Tastes even better after a RUTGERS victory. Let’s go RU! The line post game was out the door, must’ve waited 40-45 minutes. Pretty solid slice for the area, though!

Solid slice. Solid Price

had 2 slices, 1 was in the 7s, the other a mid 6. solid pizza if ur wasted tbh

All right, Frankie

The crust and undercarriage were pretty good and I thought the taste was nice. The sauce and cheese worked well together but it was a little dry. Overall it was a nice slice

Comically large pizza. Barely fit in my back seat. I had no idea. Good thin crust, nice undercarriage. Would go back

Good undercarriage. Not overly impressed with flavor. Seems like higher scores are based on the size of the slice.

When the moon aligns with the pizza star just right, Bennys hammers it home with a spectacular slice. I’ve been here many times, sometimes I’ve found it too doughy, with just not enough sauce. But tonight was not one of those nights, the stars shined down and it was a home run slice from Bennys. Crust was super thin & nicely flaky/buttery. Only critique was it could’ve had more sauce. Only thing keeping this from a truly major score. I could’ve pounded a whole pie if it was this good.

Tasty cheese. Right amount of sauce. Crust was eh. Solid pizza.

Lacking flavor in crust however very good sauce to cheese ratio and overall a very tasty massive slice.

Good under carriage. Thin and light.

Nice crisp, really good cheese

Huge slice, light on the sauce. The crust was perfect!