ryan.rutherford9/28/20, 6:38 p.m.
Huge slices are usually just a gimmick to sell less than stellar pizza. And while this pie isn’t great, it’s not nearly as bad as you might think. This is the NJ equivalent to the NYC dollar slice as far as quality goes, not price. The dough is super soft, like a dollar slice, with thick, doughy crust. The cheese is pretty standard, a generic blend that isn’t terrible. However, the sauce is surprisingly tangy and very solid, the one thing saving this pie from dipping below a 7. This joint is a staple for the after hours crowds piling in after the bars close because on a drunk pizza scale, this is a 9. But if you’re looking for a sober slice in Hoboken, this is decent; but you could definitely do better and a lot worse.
dave09115/31/20, 10:14 p.m.
Better than it should be considering a slice is the size of a baby. Minimal flop, tasty cheese and sauce but a little too doughy and needs way more crisp
alec0013/1/20, 11:52 p.m.
This isn’t the large slice, but still a decent pie. If the crust was crispier we’d be talking 7s.
deb512/20/19, 6:18 p.m.
Bigger is not always better. This was a huge slice and was completely mediocre. The ‘bubble’ took up 30% of my pizza and at one point I felt like I was eating just dough. The cheese and sauce were very unimpressive. Not sure what the hype was about this place.
forgetaboutit9/29/19, 7:01 p.m.
Average slice, no grease, no bD just an average slice, HUGE SLICE which is why i didnt guve a 6.6
andreas.kapsalis9/1/19, 4:38 p.m.
Bit too doughy for my liking but it’s very cheesy which I like. Solid slice and it fills you up.
david.o'connell8/9/19, 3:49 a.m.
This picture is after I heated it because it came cold. Second time trying this place and it's really uninspiring. If this was a 10-12 buck pie, no complaining, but it was 20 bucks. Never again.
jrzanyc7/15/19, 4:31 p.m.
Okkkkk.... If your gonna hit pizza spots in Hoboken.... you almost have to rate Benny Tudinos...Been here forever and it touts the Largest Slice in NJ.... But as we all know bigger isn’t always better... The slice is definetly huge; about the size of 2 regular slices. Prez is right, there isn’t much flop considering it’s so huge. It’s stumbled for me where most slices stumble though; on both the crust and the lack of sauce. It’s crust is pretty doughy. I want the crunch factor and I just don’t get it unfortunately. I also want a nice hearty and tangy sauce to compliment my cheese and pizza dough, and it’s basically non existent. What was on there tasted ok. But it’s hard to gauge because there is so little. They use a good quality cheese which saves them. Overall it’s a decent slice... without the slice size gimmick I may have even subconsciously scored it lower. It reminds me of a boardwalk pizza slice..... less the convenience..... soooo eh! It’s ok!
jose.santrich7/6/19, 4:08 a.m.
We had to redistribute the pepperoni but it was delicious. The cheese was a bit strong, would have been nice to taste the sauce more. The crust had a good crunch. Compared to the crap in Michigan this was an 8. If we were local probably would be closer to mid 6.
fredtesta5/7/19, 7:43 p.m.
Benny Tudino’s Pizzeria one bite everybody knows the rules,, BIGGEST FLOP YET ,,
21 views•4 likes
stephen.pfund4/20/19, 1:27 a.m.
Huge slice for $4. I like the bubbles and dough is good, but that was the best part. No crunch to speak of and nothing to say about the sauce and cheese. It's great for a late night slice.