Benny Vitali's

Decent pie. Big slice.

One of our favorite spots in the area! Affordable, huge portions and quality pizza. Take a whole pie and have trouble fitting it in your car but it’s worth it 😂

Alright pizza. Sauce had an ok flavor. Cheese had a strange texture. If you’re looking for a decent, huge, 28 inch pizza….then this is your spot.

Little flop but only cause its so large. Great crunchy thin crust. One of the best around.

Crunch gets weaker throughout eating the slice, other than that it’s really good

THEY GAD THE SHAKERS OUT!!! Very good crisp but still has a nice chew to it, and good tang. Good Slice

Huge pizza. Each slice takes up two plates. A little bit of flop around the tip, but considering the size, it’s understandable. Crust was crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. Cheese had a little bit of tang. Zero grease. Hands down some of the best New York style pizza in Virginia. I would highly recommend this restaurant which is located in a beautiful part of Fredericksburg.

Too much dough and very little sauce. Slices are huge, but would rather have a smaller slice with less dough. Everyone in the store was getting slices, yet they don’t have them ready.

Hot crisp and cheesy. One of the best slices in Fred.

Very unexpected from Virginia pizza. Good flavor and taste. Crust was delicious. Slices are huge and definitely worth the money

It’s a Virginia staple, Benny’s is legit the best pizza in this state.

Not horrible for Virginia. I agree that it probably tastes better shitfaced at 2am. If size was a factor, they’d score extra points

Not a bad slice. Definitely can get a nice NY fold out of it. I went with the pepperoni and my kid had the cheese. Can’t complain about either. Really good slices and one did the job. Stuffed

Crispy crust, awesome additions. New York bar pizza enlarged to Virginia size slices. Best pie in VA

28 inch pie!!! Very cool place.

Had the Jalapeño and Bacon slice 🤤

Banger spot for college kids, exquisite pie

Benny’s is Benny’s. Better on some days than others in my opinion, getting a good crispy reheated slice is probably the best. Good pizza for being kind of gimmicky. Cool old school pizza shop look to the inside.