Benny's Big Time Pizzeria

Great sauce, solid undercarriage, really good red sauce

Good pizza but overhyped. Excellent crust but nothing special about cheese or sauce.

Ordered the “Corleone” pizza and added pepperoni, as well as hot honey. The only good thing about this pizza was the toppings and the homemade hot honey. The dough was NOT IT. Chewy to the point that it made my jaw hurt ✋🏼

Great undercarriage and awesome crust

Great crust, good sauce, just a tad too greasy. Overall good pie and cool dining experience

The Grandmother (square) is absolutely phenomenal! I ordered mine with extra sauce and slight char and holy shit! I’m blown away. A Legit 8.5. The “Old Timer” is like a traditional Philly area tomato pie. Very good as well! The “grandma” competes anywhere.

Great Grandma Slice.

Neapolitan pizza done right 🔥

Excellent quality. Too much burn on the undercarriage but I will be back

Best pizza in Wilmington hands down. Cross between bar pie and football pizza. Great sauce and cheese.

Great artisan pizza. Kinda like a Neapolitan style, lots of flop. Not my favorite style of pizza but definitely loved it. Will be coming back

AMAZING! One of the best pizzas I have had In wilmington. Extremely juicy and tasty pepperoni. I had the Tony pepperoni.

Good fresh ingredients. The sauce is what makes this stand out. Great flavor. Neapolitan style pizza. Crust had good char and crisp but is floppy. Definitely a good date night pizza. One is big enough to share for two people but ordering a tony pepperoni is a good second pie too.

You won’t find a better pizza in Wilmington NC

Good hits of fresh mozz. Super doughy. Wish this thing had had like 5 more mins in the oven. Thinned out in the middle. Hoping for some char/crisp. Good atmosphere inside. Specialty pizzas are deffo the jam here. Bring your skinny jeans and bad attitude so we can talk about rare vinyl and succulents.

Very good, a little more gourmet than your normal pie.

Had the “The one with shrooms” pie. Thick crusted and thin sliced. Great flavors. Especially enjoyed the sesame seeds. Top with their signature hot honey sauce!

Pretty good. Hot honey is a must.

Sgt Peppers

Great crisp. Needs more sauce. Order a side of marinara to dip the outrageously large crust in.

The pepperoni pizza was small, enough to for 1 person. I’m not a huge fan of Neapolitan pizza but it was pretty good. Crisp around the edges but a good dough in the middle, had a nice spice too. Good date night pizza. The Old Fashion was better than the pizza in my opinion. But I’m a football pizza guy anyways.