Probably the closest perfect slice of Pizza I ever had!!
dylan.greenwood7/26/22, 1:58 p.m.
Similar to the other locations, in Brooklyn and New Paltz but doesn’t beat the original place. Definitely the best in the montauk area.
aces_life_style7/16/22, 2:23 a.m.
Great tomato sauce not amazing crust good cheese best pizza in the Hamptons (it is a dive bar)
nblack886/27/22, 10:10 p.m.
Can tell Best Pizza knows what they’re doing. Great sauce taste, good cheese ratio. Despite being a reheat slice, had excellent crisp in every bite.
sean.shamloufar6/19/22, 5:45 p.m.
It’s everything it was hyped up to be. This pizza and where it’s located will blow you away. Done sleep on the “grandmas pizza”. Friendly staff and bar atmosphere!
jay.marine1/17/22, 10:28 p.m.
Put this place on your bucket list or whatever list you got… cool atmosphere, and pizza is SO good. I clearly scored the regular, but that Grandma with garlic and pepperoni was a 9.4 for me. One of the best slices I’ve ever had… ever.
michael.mmq1/10/22, 5:10 a.m.
Perfect crust, great all around slice, it’s a light slice, not in weight but eatability, great ingredients. Excellent work, good staff, fun bar. Thank you.
joey.stipek10/23/21, 9:08 p.m.
The basil on the slice was unexpected but appreciated. White Pie slice is easily an 8.8 slice.
ryanloewy8/29/21, 5:57 p.m.
Perfect pizza Franklyn. Marinara is phenomenal, undercarriage crispy and crunchy, with fresh cheese. The best of the best Franky. That’s a fucking review!!!
alex.hartelust7/26/21, 4:08 p.m.
“Best Pizza” was delicious, similar to the one in Brooklyn. Crispy, sauce was amazing, and thin.
patrick.mormile7/24/21, 6:52 p.m.
Left in the oven slightly too long for underchar, but all the ingredients combined for an incredibly refreshing slice with a crust of high integrity
nico.ellis7/24/21, 6:25 p.m.
As far as a beach pie goes, this is fantastic. Pizza was super fresh, not a lot of grease, nice oregano and basil. Cheese is very good. Not a lot of flop, nice char, and great crust. Nothing to knock here, great pizza.
brendan.greenwood17/20/21, 8:48 p.m.
Great Pizza. Not a traditional flavor even better. Nice crisp. Best pizza on the east end of the island on the south fork.
avadolce7/9/21, 2:09 p.m.
This pizza was insane. NO FLOP🙌NO GREASE🙌sauce was good cheese was good. I ate three slices felt like Joey chestnut but it was well worth it.
paulie.pizza6/30/21, 1:00 p.m.
Great char, very good ratio nice air in crust with very good crunch. Good overall flavor, the Cuppone oven makes it happen. Flour is a little too strong and needs a little lower protein. Fresh pie may be different