An “8.4” Prez, really? I think you need to take a break from the reviews because your number system is flawed. Best Pizza checks off everything you want for a high quality NY slice: Light crispy crust, a simple savory tomato sauce, fresh mozz, & perfectly chopped basil. After years of mediocre pizza, the Hamptons/Montauk finally has a go-to spot that will always leave you more than satisfied. 9.4... that’s a review.
sgt.pizza1/27/21, 11:56 p.m.
Regular: I liked the best in Brooklyn a little more but its practically the same. 8.9 Grandma: i actually liked this one better than the one in Brooklyn. It was a little thinner and had a better undercarriage. Sauce and cheese were the same. 8.5
dominic.annese1/6/21, 8:10 p.m.
Good grandma pie. Very greasy, no flop. Not as good as umbertos
stefan.cedar12/5/20, 6:16 a.m.
Friend from out of state visited during the summer. Told me BPDB had a great vibe and even better pizza! Had to try it so I visited recently and It. Did. Not. Disappoint! This place knows pizza & I’m looking forward to going back this summer!
deegee11/24/20, 12:10 a.m.
No flop, crunchy crust. Cheese is tasty, sauce is tangy. Like the touch of the basil. Really good slice
arthur.wagner11/8/20, 7:06 p.m.
Outstanding pie. Great crust, crispy lepoard char on bottom fresh basil finishes it off. You definitely will want to stop if you are anywhere near Montauk. Best pizza on the East end of Long Island no doubt.
charles.pressner10/16/20, 11:27 p.m.
Best Pizza in the Hampton’s hands down. Some of the best pizza I’ve had anywhere. Place has an awesome vibe and great staff.
glizzyshlong9/5/20, 5:36 p.m.
This was a great fucking slice. It’s kind of a neopolitan style taste. Same for it well done so it’s very crispy. They could have definitely added more cheese but still very good.
edward.welsh8/30/20, 6:14 p.m.
The crust on this slice is insane. One of the best crusts I’ve ever had. Was a bit light on the cheese though and the sauce was good but a bit understated. Above average slice that could be 9+ easily with some tweaks to the sauce and cheese.
anthony.celano8/28/20, 7:23 p.m.
Drove two hours to get here it’s a beautiful day so we took a ride . Pizza was very good thin with some crisp very flavorful would I drive two hours again no but it’s good.
joe.iavaroni8/19/20, 8:38 p.m.
I know, I know I was supposed to have a full pie for which I had three in the car, to take to my kids, we’re staying at the Surf Club in Montauk so I took these 2go pizzas for my review
28 views•2 likes
jared.vignola6/11/20, 7:56 p.m.
Really...pizza looked and smelt great but had 0 taste. I can see why the ratings are so high because people out here don’t know what good pizza is. Nothing great at all.
pizza.slave4/16/20, 11:40 p.m.
Honestly bomb. Truly incredible. Crisp crust I actually enjoy eating to the end. Clearly high quality cheese (made in house) and thin thin crust.
mike.blazowski4/10/20, 10:38 p.m.
Thin and Crisp, great sauce, great quality cheese. Ingredients are all top quality.