Hoping it was an off day for the pizza maker.
calimondi7/26/20, 6:52 p.m.
Huge bummer definitely not worth the hype. It was soooo chewy, no crunch or crisp. Solid flavor though 👌🏻
forgetaboutit6/26/20, 12:19 a.m.
Not sure if i got a bad slice cause it was far from the best! Cheese was ok but the crust was like cardboard. Tasty sauce and basil, i had high hopes. Maybe i have to go back but Franky, this barley got into the 6s.. only thing that saved it was the flavor of the sauce
jerbraska6/25/20, 5:59 a.m.
Best thing about the pizza was the crust. Tastiest crust Ive probably had anywhere even the places Id give a 9. But thats about it. Everything else was pretty average. I really wanted to like it more, but I dont see how Prez ranked this in the 9’s unless the crust really got to him.
kirsch4/24/20, 11:32 p.m.
Solid pizza choice for us tonight to #supportlocal need to try it fresh!
ryan.rutherford4/23/20, 8:03 p.m.
😴SLEEPER ALERT😴 While I’m not a fan of the name of this joint (googling Best Pizza is confusing AF when you’re trying to find this place), they do make a pretty terrific pie. Very similar to some of Brooklyn’s finest pizzerias, they use fresh basil to enhance the flavor of the sauce and class up the pie. The sauce has lots of pizzazz: a fantastic combination of tangy and sweet with plenty zip. The dough is fairly thin, very tasty and decently crispy. The crust has excellent crisp, one of the best parts of the pie. While the cheese is delicious and has fabulous texture, I could definitely use a little bit more of it. Add a little more cheese & crisp up the dough as well and we’re talking about a pizza in the 9s. Even though this spot isn’t mentioned with the “Big Time” Brooklyn pizzerias, don’t sleep on this joint.
garrett.fruchtman4/22/20, 7:23 p.m.
Every time I drive On the BQE it tells me that I am near Best Pizza and Dave rated it a 9.1. So I stopped there today. Pizza was really good but there’s no way that it’s 9.1. Dave must’ve been thrown off by the goats.
almi4/16/20, 4:06 a.m.
I think I'm being super generous. My pie was ot great, I'm seeing better pies from other people but mine was not good. The dough keeps it alive but the flavors and amount of cheese not so much. It needs ricotta, it just does. Nothing more to say.🤷♂️
jay.marine4/5/20, 1:59 p.m.
Ok, finally. I frigged something up when I left this review and it posted without me commenting ~ can’t have that! Can’t just put 8.2 on a GOOD slice, God know I have something to say when it’s NOT good or just average.. lol. Ok, this is another Dave spot. He gave it a 9.1 I believe. I’m not going that high because I feel it could have had more cheese.... but the CRUST on this slice ~ quite possibly best I ever had, no lie. It was amazing. And the place inside, although basic, has a cool vibe in it. Loved it.