Best Pizza

Layla and I had Best Pizza. It was great but it’s better fresh out of the oven. Great crush.

Very very good pizza. If my last slice was more consistent throughout the rest of the pie I would be scoring this well over a 9.

Zero flop. Great crust. Ratio of sauce to cheese to crust could be slightly better, but delicious slice overall.

Crispy thin cheesy Elite

Solid pie

Literally the Best Pizza.

The slice was ok, very thin, not enough sauce or cheese. The square was thin too, the crust was fuller, not cheesy, the sauce did taste good.

Best slice I’ve ever had. I prefer a little more sauce, or it’d probably been in the 9s for me.

Zero flop and super crispy

Good pizza very good slice

Went with wife and 6 kids of various ages, and everyone scored it 8.5 and higher… great great pizza

Really good, tasted unique and ate it at McCarren Park which was nice too

Awesome pizza. Thin and great sawwwwce

My new benchmark Pizza spot some might say Lucalis is better but try getting in the best pizza for a slice shop is equally good

This is a good slice, but not as good as I was expecting given the prior reviews I’ve seen. Also, while this doesn’t affect the score, it’s worth noting that the service wasn’t great either. I’d probably only come back here if I happen to be in the area.

Quality ingredients, great crust

This is pretty damn amazing. Almost no flop, great char.

Okay best pizza. Not the best pizza I ever had. But pretty fucking good. I don’t know where the PorkBoy gets off giving them a 9. That’s crazy to me. This pizza is the embodiment of the Williamsburg. It looks old school, it follows the tradition of New York, but it has its new school values. It’s like the owner had Luigi’s and Difara and tried combining them. Hey look it’s admirable. But nothing taste better than authenticity. And Best Pizza lacks that. The pizza needs more heart to be great. This pizza has no heart. It has no soul. It’s liberal pizza. It’s “I’d vote for Obama for a third term” pizza. It’s “I just moved here from Bumfuck Idaho and this is what I’ve always heard about New York style pizza” That all being said I’m giving it a 7.8. It’s definitely a good quality slice. If you had one too many IPA’s or exhausted from dog walking. Stop into Best Pizza and grab yourself a Left Wing Slice. Trump 2024