Underwhelming. Good pizza, good sauce, above average pizza.
Order now on Slice
Order Best Pizza
Hungry? Order right now on Slice
gagebrown5/28/23, 1:28 a.m.
Great pizza! Not hitting the 9s for me, but flavor is better than most.
sam.kahane5/12/23, 12:14 a.m.
Best square? Maybe. Best triangle. Not so sure. Very good, but wouldn’t say best ever
lorenzo.russo15/1/23, 1:01 p.m.
Got it reheated so would deffo be better if it was fresh, nonetheless high quality ingredients, great crunch, worth the trip even with the rain.
evan.raphael4/15/23, 11:16 p.m.
These slices had a tangy and herbal sauce which complimented the rustic-ness of the dough. This place is probably a little overhyped considering Dave’s 9.1 rating. But it is a solid no frills pizzeria!
cliff.jones4/12/23, 6:08 p.m.
Amazing sauce and cheese, not too heavy, not greasy, temp just right, perfect crust, took it down 0.5 bc cheese slice a bit burned on the bottom, otherwise amazing. Tried the grandma slice too which was 🤌
troginfinity4/7/23, 12:12 a.m.
Very thin, light, and airy. Really fresh and bright. A perfect NY slice.
jonathan.lebram4/6/23, 9:29 p.m.
Very good NY Slice. Barely any flop, perfectly charred undercarriage, good crust. Only downside was the sauce and cheese, while good, were not as elite as some other top places I’ve been to.
elyseparker3/24/23, 3:30 p.m.
Solid slice, would obviously be better if eating a fresh pie. No flop, very thin but crispy. Good flavor but nothing really sticks out as unforgettable.
tone44993/19/23, 11:42 p.m.
Wow, Dave got this one all wrong! 9.1, WTF! I ordered a large cheese and what a disappointment. No crisp and so doughy. How does this come close to New Haven pizza? What a joke this place was. I should’ve of known better with “Best” in the name. Does anyone feel the same?
brian.dinan2/22/23, 4:17 a.m.
A really flavorful slice. Great taste on the cheese. I tried their location in Montauk back in 2020, and it was every bit as good. Reasonably priced, and well worth the trip for some excellent pizza.
tbocchino942/3/23, 7:10 p.m.
Delicious slices, had to go back and get a grandma. All 3 were a 9+ sauce to cheese on point, great crisp. Ambience is dope too
yawncave1/10/23, 4:07 a.m.
Fantastic crust, not much else going on. Everything seemed to be good quality, good vibe inside. Garlic knots weren’t knots and were about a 5.1 but the sauce was great - bit of kick.