Best Pizza on first

Great crust, sauce is pretty good (a bit tangy), good cheese but a bit too oily, EXCELLENT crispy pepperoni.

Not the best pizza on 1st… not even the best pizza on the block. Serviceable but not gonna be your best option. Sauce is a little too strong in the wrong ways and the cheese doesn’t bring anything special. Solid crust doesn’t make up for its shortcomings

Crust is thicker like football pizza but sauce and cheese make it a good neighborhood slice. Split between a 6.9 & 7.1

pretty good dough, sauce good cheese alright. This is a more of a thinner slice. Their sicilian is better than their plain might be because lighter amt of sauce on pretty thin plain

Very good neighborhood pizza. The pizza around here is definitely better then average.

Good slice, thin nice sauce, crispy,, nice char. Just like Dave reports! Good guys working there and a guy spinning pie like 75 mph!👍

Decent slice sexy score

Not quite sex but a pretty good slice.

This pizza was not the Best Pizza on First Ave., as advertised, but it was definitely pretty good. A little too much cheese, but it was not too greasy and was tasty. The sauce was very good. A little garlicky but it made it better. Nice crust. My daughter and I agree with a 7.4.

Solid nyc slice

Really good. Nothing else to say.