Big John's Pizzeria

It’s my own fault for ordering a pizza with pesto instead of pizza sauce. But chicken, bacon, and pesto not bad at all.

Buffalo Chicken pizza is the best pizza I have had here hands down. Extremely crunchy bottom, thin, great taste

Had the Godfather pizza. Very good, maybe a bit oily? But in a good way. Crust was very good. A good Key West spot to take back to your room.

Good pie and was done fast. Garlic knots are fantastic.

Solid slice, nice and crispy with good flavor. Little greasy and doughy but that’s right up my alley. Would recommend for anyone staying in the keys.

A bit greasy but still ok pizza

Good crust with a little crisp. Cheese and sauce are middle of the road. Not the worst, not the best. Good hangover pizza.

Low flop good crust Best pizza in Key West

Thicker than your typical New York style zesty sauce fairly average cheese light spiced pepperoni

One of the better slices I’ve had in the Keys. A little too much dough for me. Bring the greasiness down and that score would go up.

Pretty good, but could use some work. Super greasy and the sauce was missing something. However, the crust was great and the cheese tasted pretty good.

Cheesy, flaky crust but a little greasy and the sauce could use more flavor.