Big Mario’s was my first pizza experience in Seattle. It’s solid, but not my favorite. Def a huge flop. Probably wouldn’t eat sober.
jason.gaona9/16/20, 3:53 a.m.
Nothing to rave about here. You’re typical late night pizza. If you’ve had a few drinks it’s nice, but nothing to rave about. 6.6, that’s the review.
bigdawg266/24/20, 12:03 a.m.
Not very good pizza. Very greasyWith lots of flop. The sauces isn't to bad. The cheese is like plastic. Just stay away from this place
bigpump3/6/20, 12:57 a.m.
heavily underrated. standard slice is very solid. sometimes oily. usually minimal flop but i tend to ask for it to be crispy when reheated. square slice is light & fluffy, but also sturdy & crispy. sauce is balanced. usually a little light on cheese though. overall one of the best spots in the city.
10 views•1 like
andy.poulsen1/16/20, 7:30 p.m.
Good pizza! I think like a 3 dollar slice I’m not mad at it. Great crisp on the crust, perfect! Good tang on the sauce and cheese was good, but the cheese was pretty light a little more cheese would bump the score up. Good New York style by the slice spot! That’s a review.
luc.birchfield1/4/20, 6:58 a.m.
One of the best I’ve had in Seattle so far. Cheese is good but a little greasy, but sauce has great tang and crust is crisp with only a little flop. Definitely go try it.
mbblodge11/16/19, 8:53 p.m.
About on par with the other locations, but giving the slight edge to Fremont location which I gave a 7.4
michael.digricoli9/11/19, 5:00 a.m.
Wow- first west coast review. Interesting to say the least. The place had a lot of character, much like its sauce that had a very particular flavor that I could not figure out if I was a fan of or not. Bottom line the sauce was different, a nice change I needed in my life. Slice was slightly doughy, but in a great way. The crust was perfect and cheese up there with it. Overall a good place, and would return when I’m in the area again.
brett.tobin106/27/19, 3:46 a.m.
This a solid slice. Crust is good, the right chewiness, sauce is tangy, could use a bit more cheese, but all in all a decent slice of pizza
robagool2/22/19, 6:40 a.m.
For Seattle this is a really good slice and would recommend to anyone. Good drunk slice for sure. A little too greasy and thin but they nail NY style probably more than some of their competitors
sweetjewish12/16/18, 2:56 a.m.
one bite everyone knows the rules. Classic slice, little taste. better than most in the area. drunk or sober it’ll take care of la familia.
eric.hansman12/11/18, 5:49 a.m.
Strong slice. Piping hot and fresh out of the oven. Pepperoni is the gold medal slice don’t challenge it. Doesn’t quite top Pagliacci but it’s close.
michael.corona12/10/18, 6:09 p.m.
Straight out of the oven. 8.2. Crust could be crispier. Sauce was great.