Big Mario's Pizza

Good undercarriage. Not overly greasy. Matches my New York style. A little bit of flop with the cheese slices. Yum!

Good thin crust, could've been a bit crispier. Sauce had nice tang and overall good flavor. Needed that extra couple mins in the oven.

Yummy pizza in the neighborhood. Crispy, good toppings, great atmosphere!

Huge flop. Paper thin. Cheese sauce combo is decent. Sauce is a little spicy, liked it though. Would eat it again, but wouldn’t go out of my way.

Got a pepperoni-mushroom pie with lots of pepp and not that much mushroom. Taste-wise the toppings weren’t exceptional. Pretty good crust, a bit floppy, but overall decent NY-style pizza.

Not bad not great. Decent flavor and this time not much flop (No flop is a good thing). Onwards

Probably one of the best Big Mario’s slices I’ve had. Way better than Cap Hill used to be on a Friday night, haha. Solid sauce and crunchy crust

Great places for slices. The pep has some spice to it and the pizza had flop and grease to it.

For the greasiest pizza in town... close this joint down. Dining in they force you to listen to profane disgustingly loud rap music... every other word was N word, F bomb or some other terrible degrading lyric about women. Why would you serve mediocre pizza and then bombard patrons with vile loud music... I witnessed patrons leave the restaurant because of that filthy music.

I think I’m being a little generous because my wife was saying her crust had no crunch to it. However both of my slices did and the flavor was there. Pretty big slices too, not jersey shore big, but bigger than I’m used to out here. Anytime I’m into the 7s out around the PNW it’s a good day for pizza!

It was a good night for Mario, whoever that big guys is

Good solid slice. Tang. Crisp. Boom.

Good pizza. Ate it in an Uber after Mono concert. Nice and meaty. Didn't get grease on shirt, that's a plus. Would rather during a divisional game, but but a championship series. Come here. Rookie score is deserved

Good flop. Thin crust, crunchy. Quite possibly the best pizza in Seattle.

Fire

Lots of flop, but nice cheese and sauce.

Great for Seattle. Average for NY

Good flop. Good cheese. Good sauce. Just good. A Seattle 7.2, but a New York 6.4.

This pizza is really great. It’s the closest thing in Seattle to New York pizza. A little flop, a little greasy, but overall awesome flavor. The crust, cheese and sauce are all spot on. Great place to grab a slice in Fremont.