connor.and.elora7/4/23, 11:51 p.m.
Family from NY tries Minnesota pizza, not bad but just can’t compare. Added up all 5 scores and averaged out. Highest came in a 6.7
dirty_dyl6/25/23, 5:24 a.m.
Wow just wow. Amazing crust and perfect cheese ratio. The undercarriage is perfect best crust I’ve had. For a plain cheese I really wanted this to be a 9s score but sauce was inconsistent and lacked a hint a flavor but this is a great pizza! Well done black sheep! 8.7
davis.spaid6/15/23, 1:30 a.m.
Held up to the standard. Way better than anything I’ve had in CA. Way better
dhart785/14/23, 2:21 a.m.
It was just alright. Maybe expectations got me wanting more… crust taste like a saltine cracker, no cheese pull to it, not much sauce. looks amazing but looks aren’t everything
preston.bowman1/15/23, 12:44 a.m.
Everything about this place is an 8+, the vibe, the drinks, the coal oven, the dough, the cheese… but the sauce for me leaves a bit to be desired. Can’t quite place it but it drops it to a 7.9 for me. Still, great pizza and place. Highly recommend.
beefboss1/8/23, 2:12 a.m.
Crust is good, maybe cook it a little longer, sweet sauce which isn’t my favorite but overall good.
tony.swing12/31/22, 10:51 p.m.
Great pie! I know it’s an MN favorite but it isn’t mine. Sauce is incredible with an amazing crust. Something always seems missing when I get this pizza. Solid none the less!
e.det11/22/22, 7:22 p.m.
Crisp was great, flavor was awesome buut could have used a little more cheese
greg.kassab6/29/22, 10:07 p.m.
Way overrated by my experience. No cheese and I like light cheese but this was about a tablespoon full. Too damn much pepperoni. Potential but Very disappointed.
adam.w44/20/22, 5:18 a.m.
Got the regular pie and the Sicilian. I think the round pie is better, but both are really good
pizzajesterjason2/25/22, 4:42 a.m.
It’s judgement day….. If you have a nice atmosphere at your pizza joint, you automatically got an average pizza in my book. Black sheep had an amazing atmosphere and dining area, and my friends and I were very pleased with the service. Now for the pizza, it was really good pie! Nice crunchy crust, not a ton of flop, sweet tasty sauce, and some nice cheese. My only complaint really is that I would like my pizza a little more cheesy if the crust is that crispy. Overall I think it is an 8.4 really solid pizza. We also tried the pepperoni and that was even better than the cheese! I would rate that one a 8.6!
pizzamanmason2/24/22, 11:06 p.m.
It’s judgement day for black sheep coal fired pizza, So far right off the bat great atmosphere the server we have here very very nice person doing a real good job at getting us what we need and always take care of us. forks just came out and let’s just say there were assorted in a very neat way some of that I would definitely contribute to what I’m going to score this overall pizza. So far everything That can go right is gone right it all just seems too good to be true so far we’re just kind of waiting on our pizza here and let me tell you what we did order more than 12345 pizzas so I mean we’re not gonna knock it against him a time because they’re working hard back you there and we’re just having a good time and it’s just all good good time golfing I golf on the TVs, awesome brew stand and overall just overall good experience whilst waiting for our food. Pizza just arrive this thing is one of the best things I’ve ever seen really good at first glance no grease, Great looking undercarriage. Space pepperonis larger than I thought around here we go out for the class of cheese slice and looking out for me and my body is beside me you’re actually getting a cheese so I’m gonna make a little so I trade with him one cheese for 1 cup gonna make for a good deal and that’s when I’ll give you my score. Now I’ve had my pizza devoured the great pizza. I first I had that I thought it had some New York flop and I took a more deeper analysis and found out that it was due today and obviously we don’t do our reviews of pepperoni around here as I mention my buddies around me how to classic cheese I took my classic first buy one but everybody knows the rules and why I was I am is the absolute crunch of the undercarriage the cheesy cheese and the sweetness of the sauce shrunk my palate is an experience I can’t I simply can’t put in the words but overall on buying everybody knows the rules it is judgment day I’m given the classic cheese an 8.4. However I did end up getting pepperoni pizza which I would tell you is better than the classic cheese and I’m giving the classic pepperoni and 8.7. Overall a very good pizza and to this point the best I’ve had. Definitely a spot I recommend to everyone that is in the area and an overall great score after all it was judgment day.
trevan.clark232/10/22, 4:07 a.m.
Best pizza I’ve ever had in my life up to this point. It’s my re-review because first time I had pepperoni. It’s a much different pizza just cheese. Absolutely incredible pizza! Worth traveling for. My best score to date. Love it.
jacob.lehr2/9/22, 7:38 p.m.
Arguably the best pizza in Minnesota, black sheep is great. Very tangy but could use some more cheese. Crust is delicious. Pepperoni is better than cheese.
taylor.pettis2/6/22, 6:17 p.m.
Nice coal fire flavor. Lots of sauce and well done crisp. This place is pretty good!
flightgeb1/21/22, 11:22 p.m.
I ate the pizza too fast to take a picture of it….this is easily the best pizza in Minneapolis