Blue Steel Pizza Company

Not sure what I am missing. Crust is pretty well done and cheese is ok. The sauce is thin and watery. This is not what is was expecting. May have gotten unlucky but the score is fair, maybe even a bit high. I don’t really like this pizza.

Delicious! Crust is perfect and a lot of flavor in this. So good!

Wish they made it in this beautiful oven that was in front of us… but Airy crust, crunchy ronis. Still slammin

Great Detroit style, however small pie and expensive

Not the best pic but this was a great Detroit style pizza. I thought the pizza was very good, not my favorite style but ingredients and crust were on point. Honestly the restaurant/other items on the menu were better. recommend going and at least trying

Great air and not dense. Soft and light crust with good balance. Interesting flavors on top and the pie was cooked perfectly.

Great pizza. Light and crispy. They definitely started to put more sauce on the slices.

Great flavor. Good amount of sauce, cheese and crunch.

Pretty legit Detroit style spot. Got the Eggplant one, taste is really good, got some crisp (could use more), but it's a heavy sinker with the normal + ricotta. Took some time to come out, but we had an early lunch. Could go higher, perhaps one of the other pizzas would be better. Other food here is great too, Dan Dan noods 8.8

Not a gimmick place, legit good pizza. I’m a thin crust guy like Angeloni’s but was definitely vibing with it. Nice atmosphere in there. Sauce had just the right amount of tang and consistency. Not as heavy as some other Detroit style or Sicilian. Burnt cheese crust was perfect and good crunch. Corner slice ftw. Dave needs to try it, see how it stacks against the other Detroit places.

Nice place on the inside. I strongly recommend this place to those who like Detroit style pizza, I've come to realize it's not for me, but this is the best Detroit style I've had.

What can’t I say about this it lived up to the hype for me and I’m starting to love Detroit style. AmaZing taste. Crust buttery pillowy goodness caramelized crust to die for. The mozz is awesome but the fresh grated parm is what sets this off with the cheese. But bar none the sauce stands on its own, amazing taste and texture. For what this style is value is fantastic. For a new place this has garnered quite the reputation and deservedly so with a menu I’d like to come back for.

Not your typical NJ pizza, but it’s always good to try something different and Blue Steel offers just that. The Detroit style pizza is a thicker rectangular pie that offers a variety not normally experienced here in NJ. Loved the sauce, good cheese, and the charred edges of the crust were great. I must say it’s a very filling pie though. I knocked back 4 slices and was stuffed. Definitely recommend.

Eaten best with a fork and knife. cheese has a fantastic flavor. ordered 2 pizzas the middle of both slightly raw. It’s basically DiGiornos. honestly not a fan of the whole sauce on top of my pizza. it makes a mess. SCORE SAVER is the crust.

This Detroit-Style pizza is fantastic. Portnoy would give this detroit style above an 8 for its crispy crust and robust sicilian style sauce. It’s not overwhelming, light & fluffy dough. Honestly no downsides. Just get the classic.

Surprisingly light for being a thick crust. Relish overpowered the vodka sauce for me. Would get again with no relish. Inside is really cool, would definitely go back.

New Detroit Style pizza spot in Bloomfield. Im biased cause Detroit is my favorite style but this place does it right. Super crispy crust, great sauce, brick cheese and the pecorino and fresh Oregano is a nice touch. Love it.

Detroit style square pizza joints are popping up all over the NY/NJ area in an attempt cash in on new and trendy ways to make pizza. The squares are considered Detroit style and not Sicilian cause they do not have a crust. They are baked right up against the walls of a steel pan, which makes the edges a nice combo of burnt & crispy. The pizzas are smallish, 8x10 in size, shareable or personal depending on your appetite. If Little Caesars & Pizza Hut merged and started a slightly upscale pizzeria, this it what it would look & taste like. Not as basic as those chains, fancier, but not as good as I had hoped. The dough is thick but also a little spongy; I like the crispy edges, but I prefer crust. The sauce is sweet and very tasty, solid zip and tang but it needs to be spread across the pie more judiciously. I expected a lot more flavor from the cheese; it needs some garlic or oregano to make it less dull. Overall it’s not a bad pie, it just didn’t blow me away. It’s not even close to Prince Street or L&B Spumoni squares. Worth a try if you’re interested in a different style but for the lack of size and lofty prices, I expect better.

As good as a Detroit style pizza can get!!! From the perfectly baked buttery crust to the mmm mmm mmm flawless sauce!!! I might be biased to the thin crust style that I grew up with so I just can't give this a 9. But no doubt one of if not thee best Square's out there!!!