Your typical “football” pizza. The guys behind the counter said, “this pizza is so good, you’ll be back”. Before I do return, I’d like to see the pizza cooked for an extra 2 minutes or so. The bottom was a little soggy and sloppy with just a little bite in the crust. The cheese is good, the pepperoni is subtle and I actually liked that. The sauce is a little weird, it’s seasoned and there’s a spice I can’t really pinpoint but the first few bites threw me off. I’d easily give this an 8 or higher if the pizza was cooked just a little more.
paul.lane4/15/21, 4:25 p.m.
Very good ingredients... a little soft or floppy but It’s damn good pizza.
tyler32603/7/21, 11:56 p.m.
Best pizza in WNY. Damn this is good pizza. Surprised Dave didn’t put this in the 8s. Granted he wasn’t able to taste it well done/ Double pepperoni, well done.
welltravelledpizzaguy11/10/20, 8:36 p.m.
I don’t have any complaints about it. Nothing really stood out in a good way either though. It has good taste, good crust, good cheese. Solid pizza. 7.7
sarah.neubert9/19/20, 2:43 p.m.
While in the Buffalo area, I was drawn to this place due to Dave’s highest review in Buffalo. He gave it a 7.5 but I easily give it a 9.2. This pizza was off the rails. I got mine done light well done as recommended in his review. I was most impressed by the tangy sauce and cheesy crust. So often, there isn't enough cheese and a bland crust. This cheese went all the way to the edge, so much so that there was no discernible crust. Huge fan of this pizza. When in the area again, I'll be ordering from Bocce Club!
furbytpc20199/18/20, 9:59 p.m.
Rookie score. Reminds me of.my favorite back home. Little less crisp then I would like. But really good pizza sneaking into the 8's
ed.sugg7/23/20, 9:26 p.m.
Always good. Great crust, good sauce good cheese. Big pie not as close as I was growing up. I still make the drive back.
flop_zilla7/13/20, 9:57 p.m.
Not my style. No crisp. A lot of dough and super sweet sauce. Their wings are a 9.3.
vic.krese5/15/20, 6:08 p.m.
It was just okay. There are at least 5 places in Buffalo that I enjoyed more. Buffalo has some amazing pizzerias, I’d skip this one.
p.staff7162/21/20, 6:33 p.m.
Quality ingredients. One of the better pizzas in the area. Got it “well done” but will probably get it regular next time.
tanner.bernal1/18/20, 1:40 a.m.
Love the sweet sauce, pretty decent buffalo pizza and it dont get much better then this. Cheese is balanced and pepperoni is cooked well. Will always be a favorite
angelo.vinch1/6/20, 5:41 p.m.
Never had buffalo style pizza before,so I don’t know how to judge it.. I liked the flavor, too doughy/gummy for me,unless that’s the style..next time I’ll ask for it to be more well done
justin.gospodarski12/27/19, 3:29 a.m.
Heard all the hype about this place, so I had to make my up to Amherst. It’s a good piece of pizza, but it’s nothing crazy. It’s just solid pizza. Nothing special, nothing to harp on. 7.4.