Borgata (W. Dublin Granville). 12” cheese, 12” white, 20” pep. This pizza did not live up to the expectations and hype. I like the NY style (better than the paper thin stuff around here), but it was not cooked enough. No crisp and a TON of flop. Needed another 5 minutes in the oven. Cheese and pep were quality and very good, but I felt the sauce need a little more kick. It was somewhat bland. I’m giving this a 7.4. It’s a quality pie, but not the “best in Columbus” as it’s been billed
todd.gottschall10/24/20, 9:54 p.m.
New York style pepperoni. Sauce is the best part. Tastes super fresh.
jacob.roalef3/13/20, 6:20 p.m.
Very solid New York style. Nice crisp to it. Marg pizza also pretty good.
michael.lindell2/15/20, 1:19 a.m.
Amazing pizza pie...best in Columbus. New York style pie! Come get some.
columbuspizzaking9/22/19, 5:24 p.m.
It was ok. Not great but just ok, for nyc style pizza it’s a little off the mark. We tried the pep and the Plain cheese. Just definitely does not live up to the hype.
brock.schnitzer6/18/19, 3:52 a.m.
I have had it where it’s as high as an 8.3 but overall defintely a 7.9-8.3 consistently so I am going 8.1
brandon.caldwell6/8/19, 12:16 a.m.
Great pie, paper thin skip the toppings the cheese is where it's at. That's a review Mark !
james.x5/13/19, 9:00 p.m.
Solid overall. Got half pepperoni and half cheese. 16 in. Flavor of cheese, sauce, and pepperoni were great and carried score. Grease was minimal. Crust had no crunch/crisp and had a ton of flop. Could have been in high 7s if the crust was better. Value seemed average. Would gladly eat again sometime, but likely won’t be a regular. ***caveats based on my personal preferences: I prefer the crust be crispy, small amount of flop, anti square cut, quality pepperoni, and keeping grease at a minimum.
shane.gerber3/1/19, 11:04 p.m.
This pizza has great flavor and flop. Classic pepperoni and the best crust I’m Columbus. Have to eat when the owner is in.
larry.jones11/19/18, 6:57 p.m.
Very good pizza! Little too much flop, but the best NY pizza in the area! Will be trying it again
cjhavey10/17/18, 12:59 a.m.
Quality all the way around. Lots of cheese, great flop, nice sauce with a little spice. 20” NY style at its best.