Solid overall. Got half pepperoni and half cheese. 16 in. Flavor of cheese, sauce, and pepperoni were great and carried score. Grease was minimal. Crust had no crunch/crisp and had a ton of flop. Could have been in high 7s if the crust was better. Value seemed average. Would gladly eat again sometime, but likely won’t be a regular. ***caveats based on my personal preferences: I prefer the crust be crispy, small amount of flop, anti square cut, quality pepperoni, and keeping grease at a minimum.
jjo32/20/21, 11:52 p.m.
The dude who gave this a 9.4 is nuts. It’s very good but like everyone says it’s too soft. Borgata says it’s because they put honey in their dough. Whatever the reason the flop keeps it out of the 8’s
todd.gottschall10/24/20, 9:54 p.m.
New York style pepperoni. Sauce is the best part. Tastes super fresh.
brian.taylor89/10/20, 11:53 p.m.
Borgata (W. Dublin Granville). 12” cheese, 12” white, 20” pep. This pizza did not live up to the expectations and hype. I like the NY style (better than the paper thin stuff around here), but it was not cooked enough. No crisp and a TON of flop. Needed another 5 minutes in the oven. Cheese and pep were quality and very good, but I felt the sauce need a little more kick. It was somewhat bland. I’m giving this a 7.4. It’s a quality pie, but not the “best in Columbus” as it’s been billed
jacob.roalef3/13/20, 6:20 p.m.
Very solid New York style. Nice crisp to it. Marg pizza also pretty good.
michael.lindell2/15/20, 1:19 a.m.
Amazing pizza pie...best in Columbus. New York style pie! Come get some.
columbuspizzaking9/22/19, 5:24 p.m.
It was ok. Not great but just ok, for nyc style pizza it’s a little off the mark. We tried the pep and the Plain cheese. Just definitely does not live up to the hype.
brock.schnitzer6/18/19, 3:52 a.m.
I have had it where it’s as high as an 8.3 but overall defintely a 7.9-8.3 consistently so I am going 8.1
brandon.caldwell6/8/19, 12:16 a.m.
Great pie, paper thin skip the toppings the cheese is where it's at. That's a review Mark !
shane.gerber3/1/19, 11:04 p.m.
This pizza has great flavor and flop. Classic pepperoni and the best crust I’m Columbus. Have to eat when the owner is in.
larry.jones11/19/18, 6:57 p.m.
Very good pizza! Little too much flop, but the best NY pizza in the area! Will be trying it again
cjhavey10/17/18, 12:59 a.m.
Quality all the way around. Lots of cheese, great flop, nice sauce with a little spice. 20” NY style at its best.