Borgata Pizza Cafe

Classic greasy NY slice. Lotta flop. That’s a review.

Ordered 2 pies, a sub and a salad. All were good. Server was attentive. Pizza had good ingredients dough a little thin, but had good chew. Lots of flop, and a little greasy ( lg pep) could have been cooked a couple more minutes. Salad and sub were good portions for the $$ and were good.

Surprisingly good crisp for delivery. Flavor was lacking

Decent pizza. Crust is very chewy and not flavorful but sauce is quality. Didn't wow me but wasn't bad.

Tastes a little mass produced but solid regular slice

Good sauce. Decent pep. Nice, crispy crust. Just too expensive.

Perfectly decent slice. Tons of flop but the taste of the crust was good. So was the sauce. I didn’t order a whole pie but I’m sure by the slice isn’t as good so score could be higher.

One of the best pizzas I’ve had in Columbus. Very hard to top. Flavor could not be better as it is loaded with toppings and flavor and it is very distinct. Little flop but this is the best pizza I’ve reviewed thus far

good slice!

Good, crust was reallyy soft

Asked for well done but it was still good

Great flavor - just wish the crust was a little more on the crispy side.

SEX. Cheese is great. Overall, this pizza didn’t knock my socks off but I enjoyed it

A true to god New York slice. Pepperoni is slight spicy. Sauce and cheese are good. Crust could be a bit more crisp.

Solid pie. Sauce is tangy but not overpowering, decent flop and not a ton of grease. Needs more crisp on the crust tho. Tafts still the best Za I’ve had in cbus.

Got NY style with pepperoni, sausage, and fresh mushrooms. Hot and fresh. Crust was awesome, baked perfectly. Lots of flop and cheesy but not too much grease. Decent sauce but not mind blowing. Maybe that kept it out of the 9s. Still very good. Would definitely come back if in the area again. Very good service also.

Very good thin crust pizza. The cheese is quite delicious

Excellent ingredients. Excellent service. Excellent taste. A little floppy for me. Very close to NYC pizza.

Crust has a good char flavor but it is a little bit too soft, sauce is mediocre not enough flavor, cheese is a hair above average