Borrillo's Pizzeria and Beer & Wine Garden

Not bad but nothing to write home about

This is DrB’s one bite review. Everyone knows the rules. The margarita pizza had a beautiful undercarriage, limited flop, great taste…… rating 7.4

Thin and flavorful. While the pizza is solid on its own, the delicious meatballs and good live music lifts this somewhere into the 7’s. Great atmosphere.

I couldn’t get a picture to upload but I needed to write something about this pizza. It was very greasy, not much flavor to it at all. I was disappointed because it had that old school pizzeria vibe on the outside.

THE football pizza of St Augustine. Funky cheese, tangy sauce, nice crust

Greasy but good pizza.

Very tasty Za

It’s sloppy & floppy but reliable like a trailer park girl. Would definitely put in my mouth again.

Brick Oven Goodness!

0 flop. Brick oven; but no flop. 5.6 that’s a score

Drunk pizza. That’s a review

Did a review before, had to come back because after eating at all the other top pizza spots in St. Augustine this is definitely hands down the best. All the other ones get love by the tourist and ppl downtown when they are having a night on the town and this one is kinda off the beating path but definitely better than every pizza spot within the St. Augustine area. Overall great pizza. At a minimum a 7.4, compared to the rest of st. A definitely in the 8’s, I’ll cut the difference and give it a 7.8. My go to spot from now on.

Good crust nice crunch Sauce is good nice tang needs a bit more so you get sauce in every bite

Lotsa flop. I wouldve cooked it more. Not enough sauce. Ok cheese just a avg slice. Expected more. Have had better here. They need to work on sauce game.

Big momma of a slice. Best in town

Crunchy thin crust. A little two crunchy, shredded my mouth. Taste was good. Nothing great. Average.

Love the look and the style.. the cheese seems to curdle. Crust is awesome and moved it up .7