Boynton Pizza

Average pie at best. Sauce was bland/tasteless. Toppings were the best part. Crust tasted like a frozen pizza.

In my opinion the Sicilian is their best pie, but the regular pie is also very good. I find that they typically cook their pies less than I prefer, but asking for well done typically solves that issue and results in a very good pizza. They are very consistent and the staff is also very good. My go to place for a Sicilian or standard NY style pie.

Very good pizza. Thin crispy crust, tangy sauce good quality cheese. Strictly take-out, very small store.

Great pizza… best in the area for thin and crispy.

Heavy flop, decant taste…nothing to write home about

Standard football pizza as Portnoy portrayed. Just a bit too greasy and not to much flavor

Excellent pie.. fresh, hot, perfect pull and crunch. Beautiful under carriage with just the right amount of flop… Second slice had zero flop after is cooled a little.. Overall 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

Good pizza solid under carriage great flavor on the pepperonis and a good ratio on the sauce and cheese. Only negative was a little too greasy

I stumbled On this place while following a recommendation from a different place just a few blocks away. When I clicked on it I saw David Portnoy was here and gave a 7.4, I knew I would swing right back. 1. Basically perfect in every way. The sauce, cheese and dough all were excellent. The salt content was right at the perfect level but a drop more would have been over the top. 2.Hard to improve on this slice but if anything, I guess a thicker mozzarella cheese would have put it into the 8"s catagory. 3. I lost track of the name of the pizzeria, but downtown Clearwater Florida also has Albanian people making fantastic pizza!!

Pretty decent piece of pie. The sauce and crust help the score. Good amount of pepperoni.

Nice crunch. Spicy sauce. Very good slice.

Delicious. Best I’ve had in Florida

The chicken pizza roll was a 10! Unbelievable taste w the chicken, mushrooms and mozzarella with seasoning on top. The pizza was solid basic NY style. Great sauce. Crust was soft. Cheese good. I’d definitely come back.

Go to this place many times and it’s always outstanding but the first time I go and do a review it’s under par for what I expect. Sauce was not hitting the same and could be cooked a little longer.

Yes.. this does look good, right? Had a long day at work and a hankering for a special pizza, and returned to Boynton Pizza a second time. The first time was quite good, but this one was better. While it’s unfair to judge considering I ordered sausage with roasted peppers, even though there were a few greenies in there (Go Jets), the pizza had zero flop, a tangy sauce, and was cooked exactly to my specs. We all shared at home, and my 7.8 could have been inspired by hunger and overall satisfaction in the ordering process and pickup, which included a sneak peek (nice touch), but having the freezing cold 2 liter sodas at the ready, sealed the deal for me. Son: 7.2, wife 7.5, we’ll go with an average family score of 7.5. Nice score for a friendly place. The pizza is great, owner is a hard worker too. Check ‘em out!

Better than any trash spot Portnoy went to in Boca and Miami thus far. An 8.6 for a great flop, great sauce and good crust. Best spot so far in Florida

Good flavor; great value for a slice ($2). Sauce is the best part. Thin and lightly crispy. No bubbles is a nice touch. Solid in the “6’s”. A good post-workout snack.