This one had some serious flop going on. I would call it bad but there were some issues. The sauce was soupy, the cheese is greasy and not enough crunch. Too chewy. Average.
deegee3/17/21, 11:23 p.m.
Two good slices. My new favorite spot in the area. Normal slice: slight flop, good crunch tho. Cheese was above average but there was a ton of it so that boosts it. Sauce had a nice unique taste to it. I give it a 7.8 Sicilian: pretty doughy but still had a crunch. Cheese was good and spices different than the normal slice. Sauce was tasty as well. 7.6
piesannoisseur3/17/21, 7:13 p.m.
This is what I call “football pizza”. Thick crust for NY style. Tasty sauce laid on a bit heavy though. I like cheese so didn’t mind it was also laid on heavy. I’d stop in again if I’m in the area.
funsizemike.3/3/21, 10:05 p.m.
Grandma style - greasy crispy and pepperoni perfectly charred on the edges. Bonus point for the excellent 70s original decor.
jarettdesanti1/22/21, 6:04 a.m.
Branchinelli’s Pizza Rating - 8.1/10 Great regular and Sicilian.
tcorcoran8/22/20, 4:44 p.m.
Very decent, average slice. No flop, tangy sauce. Good bang for your buck
jay.marine2/29/20, 11:11 p.m.
The place was PACKED with people. Literally a line. Everything is awesome here in my opinion ~ except the regular. Lol. The regular is average. Sicilian, White, toppings, stuffed is all phenomenal though 🤷🏻♂️ I’d def check it out for all those...
eddie.o'brien12/5/20, 6:55 p.m.
Messy slice but very good, little greasy but sauce really stands out and crispy !
zachary.worthington7/14/19, 7:10 p.m.
Usually not a sicilian guy, i say that but i have a deep burning passion for all pizza, i just usually get the thin stuff. That being said, i was told this was the place to go for Sicilian Pizza. It absolutely did not disappoint. Super good crust with that bouncy mouth feel and just a bit of crisp to the bottom. Sauce was on the verge of being more tangy than i like, maybe a pinch of sugar in that sauce but who am i to tell Branchinelli how to make his pizza?! The cheese was great and i lived that slice. The marinara slice with basil and pecorino romano was very solid too. It was a bit of a thinner style swuare with crisp edges and bottom, very tangy but bright slightly chunky tomato sauce that hasnt been drowned out by too much seasoning. Id rate that a flat 8.0. Which is a great score. That’s a review.
gattoeatspizza2/26/19, 11:15 p.m.
Really good pizza! Bonus points because one of my slices was missing the tip and he gave me an extra slice for free without me asking