About Brenda's Pizzeria
241 Yelp Reviews
stoolpresidentepgh7/5/22, 2:39 a.m.
Good pizza for the lake. Can dock the boat up right down the hill and walk up for a slice. Just your average beach pizza… but at a lake. Makes a getaway feel like a getaway, but isn’t anything crazy. Just has that distinct Chesapeake Area beach flavor to it. Since this is Review #30, I’ll give my thoughts so far: I didn’t expect much of this app to begin with. I don’t travel far for pies or plan ahead to get them. However, it’s been nice to keep a journal of the slices I’ve had so far. As an Italian, I appreciate good pizza and local shops. So, whenever I’m in an area that’s renowned for pizza, I try to enjoy the best slice I can find. Thanks for following along so far. More to come
tom.howard5/31/22, 10:46 p.m.
Pretty good. NYC decor. I wouldn’t call it NY style, but it’s solid.
kenny.schrock3/26/22, 10:08 p.m.
Pretty decent pie right here. Sauce is tasty. A little flop to the crust which I don’t mind at all. Minimal grease. Good sauce to cheese ratio. All around good football pizza.
lebrian.james2/5/22, 3:19 a.m.
My 100th pizza review, and first one in Maryland! Drive through a snow storm on the mountain to get it and was not dissapointed. Just your standard good tasting cheese pizza. Nothing crazy good and nothing bad. Sauce was on the sweeter side and it could’ve been crispier. Definitely a good pie and I wouldn’t be surprised if it’s one of the better pizza spots in Western Maryland.
dick_wiggle12/24/21, 1:08 p.m.
Really good, all around. Definitely a little “puffier” than typical NY style, but not a bad thing. Great sauce.
country_ry6/17/20, 5:28 p.m.
Great crust. Flavorful sauce. Tangy cheese. Cooked on a tray. Would have put this in the mid 8’s if it were some in a brick oven. Otherwise my ideal style pie.