I’ll chalk this bad review up to the quarantine, because all of the other reviews seem pretty good, but my slice was AWFUL! The slice looked great, but the sauce had no flavor and the crust had no crunch whatsoever. The crust was rubbery.. it tasted exactly like putting leftover pizza in the microwave. Such a disgusting slice. I’m annoyed that I wasted room in my stomach on this.
kevin.collins1212/13/19, 5:12 a.m.
Great.. crispy. They need a regular pie, not just margarita
jaydakidd12/8/19, 11:31 p.m.
What a Tastee Pizza. Nice thin and full of flavor. Great crisp with a lil New York flop.
dsbaker11/19/19, 5:51 p.m.
Very thin and crispy, and all around great slice. Would definitely come back
will.shead8/19/19, 3:14 a.m.
Excellent slice. Thin crispy crust. Only thing missing is some tang in the sauce.
mattbedross8/18/19, 6:17 p.m.
Alright, Frankie. Brick Oven Pizza 33 on 33rd and 3rd has a real good slice. I thought the Murray Hill area was littered with mediocre pizza, but Pizza 33 has silenced my ignorance. With the perfect amount of flop and crisp, the pizza is great. The crust was perfect, although I would have liked a little more. Having this pizza with a little crushed red pepper and garlic salt would garnish a higher score from me, but it’s still a great slice. If you find yourself in Murray Hill, or near the Ferry, stopping by Pizza 33 is a solid option for a bite to eat, but I wouldn’t go out of my way for it.
absolutrob8/4/19, 9:51 p.m.
Buffalo chicken way better then the regular. Good flavor to the sauce and chicken wasn’t over cooked.
colin.moore27/23/19, 3:04 a.m.
Above average cheese and crispy crust hold the slice together giving it solid flip. Sauce is nothing to write home about