Not sure where all these great reviews come from. There's nothing special about this pizza and it's so thin and non filling that I could eat 100 slices and still not be satisfied
mh4239812/15/20, 8:42 p.m.
Good but not crazy about it. Crust is super thin and very crispy but didn’t have much flavor. Part that stood out to me the most was the sauce but how they make it leaves bites without sauce. Would come back but not “go out of your way” pizza
jeff.johnstone12/10/20, 2:42 a.m.
It’s a deli spot, Dollops of sauce, almost margarita style. Thin and crispy. Flavor is average.
frank.facciponti8/1/20, 11:13 p.m.
This pizza is a little different from your normal pizza. The sauce is sweet, the dough is rolled thin, and the crust has nice crunch and flavor. It's not very cheesy and there is no grease or flop.
jerbraska7/14/20, 9:29 a.m.
See, the thing with this place is its not the plain slice that stands out. Its their tri-color pizza w/ pesto sauce. Best pesto pizza Ive ever had and Ive tried Rubirosa’s popular pesto pie. Shame Prez only does regular. He missed out.
anthony.coyle7/9/20, 5:20 p.m.
Brooklyn Boys Pizza and Deli, not your classic pizza pie I would say. Very thin pizza dazzled with spots of tomato sauce, leaving a thin and crunchy crust. Pizza had no flop and was not too greasy and as I took a bite the sauce took me away. The crust on the other hand was not a solid crust, way to thin and not nice a doughy as crust should be. Little messy as the sauce would constantly fall of the pizza due to the fold. But overall I would go 6.9
chargers10177/9/20, 1:36 a.m.
The tomato pie is excellent. Thin, light, nice sauce. Highly recommend
bigbonebroth2/22/20, 10:50 p.m.
It comes out looking like a traditional NJ pie and then you pick up a slice and boom it’s thinner than a model during runway season. Good pizza not great pizza. The boys gotta do something more to get into that great 8 territory.
jonathan.horvat2/22/20, 12:46 a.m.
Dave must have had a bad pie. Aside from not being able to order“custom slices” which I think is ridiculous, the pizza is really good. Super good crisp and the sauce has a good sweetness to it. Would come again.
george.alexandros2/11/20, 8:56 p.m.
Great "tomato pie". Awesome flavor and great crisp. Not football pizza but definitely worth the trip
tread421/27/20, 5:24 p.m.
Always a consistent slice at Brooklyn Boys Pizza. Pepperoni slice was above average. Their Chicken Parm slice is outstanding!
watson1/25/20, 9:07 p.m.
Dough cooked perfectly, crispy not burnt. Sauce is on point. A little too oily. Good pizza.
mr.saturdaynight1/22/20, 1:15 a.m.
It was very thin and crunchy yet not very flavorful. I get that it’s not your everyday slice because it’s considered a tomato pie, but There was not much cheese at all. The crust was kind of hard and a little more oily then even I prefer
zekeeatspizza1/15/20, 9:19 p.m.
Back at it. Zeke loves the sauce, very sweet. Crust is crispy. Cheese are little weak, could of used a little more maybe. Probably the only downfall. Overall very solid pie. That’s a review, Zeke
ayyyygimmeameatball1/15/20, 6:24 p.m.
Crust was electric. Nice thin crisp ultraviolet slice. Was kinda bland though
tom.brady712/13/19, 12:10 a.m.
I don’t know Dave I think you were a little low. I’m not from the area went here because I’m stayin close and seen you reviewed here. Was a damn good pizza.
nicky_eats10/29/19, 4:55 p.m.
Pretty disorganized here... waited way too long for 2 slices. Pizza is quite good though.
alex.hartelust10/3/19, 8:08 p.m.
Brooklyn Boys 🍕 Fresh ingredients and always a solid choice by my hometown.
11 views•1 like
kevin.o'connor510/1/19, 10:58 p.m.
The sauce was very good and had a little kick to it. I was a fan of the crust and there was a lot of flop. Cheese was average. This definitely isn’t something I’d have often but it’s a very good change of pace slice
jake.d239/26/19, 5:55 p.m.
Not your football pizza... high quality, thin, crispy, lots of flavor.....really good pizza