Sauce was great but the pizza itself was too crunchy for me and not enough sauce spread throughout.
repsreviews5/12/21, 5:01 p.m.
Says out front “Home of the squares” so had to go with the square. Still plain cheese of course. Crust was thick but still light with a nice crisp. Sauce and cheese didn’t really do anything special for me. Worth a try
jim.car5/5/21, 10:09 p.m.
This pizza is outstanding!!! The sauce has great zing and flavor! The cheese is not greasy at all, meaning they are using a high quality product! The pizza depicted with meat is a hot honey pizza, which was crazy good!! A must try! Customer service was awesome!
everybodyknow5therule53/9/21, 10:48 p.m.
Forgot to take a picture of the cheese pie again but it’s a 7.7. Picture is of a slice from the Brooklyn pie, easily an 8.5 it’s that good.
mikeester933/9/21, 5:45 p.m.
ZERO flop. All crunch. Great cheese, good sauce. Crust sent it over the top. Solid slice.
andy.warsewicz3/4/21, 4:38 p.m.
Nice plain slice. Crust is a bit too thin for my preference, otherwise nice crisp, sauce has just enough tang, and great seasoning.
southjerseyrich2/25/21, 9:18 p.m.
Brooklyn Upside Down pie is crispy, it's flavorful... Thinner than Spumonkey Gardens
bill.derka2/4/21, 11:28 p.m.
The drunken grandma may be the best pizza ever! The Brooklyn style was great also.
mike.zachwieja1/3/21, 1:56 a.m.
Great crisp crust. Very flavorful sauce. I would probably give a better review if I was more hungry when eating.
catch771/3/21, 1:01 a.m.
have ordered from here a few times and can say that they are really, really good. anticipate long wait times (tonites was hr and 15 at 5:45pm for pickup) but they are worth it. have tried various different round and square pies and would say my favorites are the brookyln, drunken grandma, and upside down (pictured here reheated). and they fare especially well reheated over a stove. crust is a highlight - satisfyingly light, crispy, though somewhat cracker hard on the edges. sauce tastes fresh, chunky (on the brookyln) tangy, somewhat sweet. cheese is quite nice, rich and gooey. order their squares. rounds are good but do their specialties and you'll be happy.
christina.rouhas12/5/20, 8:37 p.m.
Good pizza. Great sauce. A little salty for me. But great overall.
ron.jackson11/29/20, 7:44 p.m.
Great Sicilian Upside Down. Thin crust and very Spumonkey Gardens like but better....
mike.m4010/30/20, 11:47 p.m.
Hour and 15 minute wait for a pie, so we got slices. Tasted like leftover pizza that you tossed in the toaster oven. No flavor, stale crisp. Also, Score coulda been slightly higher if there wasn’t hair in the pizza. Should be a 0.0, but I’ll keep it honest, 5.4.
mike.modica10/23/20, 3:09 a.m.
I’ve had thousands of pizzas across the northeast. NYC, PA & Jersey. This place is easily top 5. Their stock cheese by-the-slice is fantastic, but their secondary pies are amazing too. Absolutely have to try the Drunken Grandma & Brooklyn square Pies.
brodgers210/20/20, 10:42 p.m.
Grandma pizza. Greasy and oily but good flavor. Crust is really crisp. The cheeses used are nice too.
phillypizzaguy12310/5/20, 1:05 p.m.
Didn’t know much about this place. Heard about it recently, and I will definitely say it’s one of the best places in South Jersey. Good toppings, good sauce. Definitely recommend.
ilovepizza1239/17/20, 5:29 p.m.
This pizza used to be amazing. Last few times have been quite the opposite. It’s now more disappointing than satisfying.
alexhitsbombs9/15/20, 10:57 p.m.
Sauce is a little too salty for my liking. Crust is really good and taste great the next day.