Brooklyn Pizza Authority

PROS Super thin crispy crust, Fresh homemade sauce, simple menu, quick delivery. CONS Cheese is a little greasy, crust is little dry and a little pricey

Surprisingly clear flavors, but greasy. The crust crackles pretty well, baked on the lighter side.

The average score is fair. Could have more crisp, and the sauce is too sweet. Good sauce to cheese ratio. If you have Brooklyn in your name slice the pie in 8 equal slices - not 4. The compliment is I’ve had it more than once. Not a bad slice overall.

This is my go too spot for pizza in the Midlothian area. No flop, nice crisp, and good sauce

Sauce and cheese are good and crust is light. Nothing special that makes it stand out but it tastes fresh and good quality. Above average slice

Good sauce, cheese, but dough is super cheap and has very minimal flavor. Not enough NY flop

Brooklyn Pizza Authority

No flop, but a lack of crisp on the pizza but overall really good pizza. Just a little on greasy side but a really good pizza.

Lots of flop, little flavor and too doughy.

2nd chance review: 1st time I got a slice that seemed like had been sitting for a while and it was super bland. Scored it a 5.1. Ordered a large this time. Huge pie. I forgot to order it well done, so it had big time Midlo flop. Not very greasy though, which is good. It’s better than last time, but still not amazing. The slice was inconsistent with its flavor; some bites had a good cheese flavor while the sauce was bland, other bites it was the other way around. Overall it’s decent, but there’s still not as much flavor as I’d like. Decent neighborhood pizza. 6.3 on the full pie. That’s a review.

Can’t beat the price. $3.50 for this giant slice he cut in half for me. Good solid slice

Drove about 25 minutes to get here. Based on the reviews and the photos I figured it would be worth it. It’s not. Major flop, major grease. Outside crust was pretty crisp but the rest was soggy and the overall flavor was missing something. Maybe mine was a fluke, but I won’t be finding out. I would honestly rather have a frozen Totino’s.

I'm not too big on 2nd chances, unless it's pizza. Pizza deserves a 2nd chance. Place is spitting distance from my house so here I am again. It's getting a 7.1 simply because it's better than most of the recent places I've been around here. Good piece of pie. Midlo flop like Grandmas Tits but definitely New York style. Still searching for the pie around here that's gonna make me go "YYYupp" Portnoy style but this ain't it. That's a review