Sicilian was heavy on the garlic, ny pie was undersalted
carlosalvarez3/11/21, 5:10 a.m.
My scale is really off pie wise. I actually got an ooni so I haven’t had anyone else’s pie in a while. This is probably the best I’ve had in Jax, I admire Pizza Cave and how unique their taste is but I’m a New York and New Haven guy at heart and this is easily the closest you can get to that here. I wish it was a bit crunchier and there’s a certain tang to the sauce that I can’t quite describe but the overall experience is about as good as you’re gonna get it for Florida pizza.
payton.sullivan12/29/20, 10:33 p.m.
Good flop and excellent flavor!! Extra probs bc its fresh!!! Great New York pizza!
robby.wander11/27/20, 8:12 p.m.
Straight sixes. Likely a consistent pie. Overall, very satisfying. *from November 20, 2020
kenneth.scott18/22/19, 4:06 p.m.
Nice big slices. Plenary of flop. Slice wasn’t over cooked. One bite everyone knows the rules. Sauce has a nice flavor that doesn’t overwhelm the pallet. Dough is thin and crunchy how I like it.
whataretherulesagain7/28/19, 10:04 p.m.
Been here a couple times, good pizza. Average New York Style Pizza in FL. There are a couple better choices that are a little further away but this is conveniently a mile from my apartment. Wouldn’t travel for it, and still chose to travel for others but because it’s so close I still go from time to time. Review: Big ole Bartram Park flop but edge of the crust had good crunch. Not doughy at all, thin with good flavor, can’t tell if it was the cheese or sauce but there was definitely some tang. Wish the crust had more of a flavor other than just the char.
john.tommasello6/17/19, 1:15 a.m.
Well Frankie, one bite everyone knows the rules. Well cooked pie but not enough to give the pie a nice crunch that it most definitely deserved. I’m a huge toppings guy so I like it loaded and they definitely didn’t let me down. Nice and heavy slice. The crust was thin and I didn’t care for that too much. I enjoyed the hospitality of the Italian family that owned the place but sadly that doesn’t play into the rating of the pizza.
juan.escobar5/19/19, 11:41 p.m.
Crust was chewy, flavor was great though. Could t get over the lack of crunch in the crust.
pat.reilly25/17/19, 4:16 p.m.
One of the chewiest pizzas I've had. Crust is crunchy but undercrust takes some serious jaw work to masticate. Good cheese to sauce ratio. But the sauce has a unwelcome zing.
jeff.harden5/4/19, 10:36 p.m.
The people going 8+ are out of their mind, maybe in the low 7s on a good day, but 6.6 is the score. Decent pizza, good crisp, good flavor, New York atmosphere. Need a good football pizza, go for it. Need to travel 10+ minutes for a pizza, no way.
imabricktree9/19/18, 7:43 p.m.
Flop for days. Good sauce minimal grease. Solid football pizza. One bite everyone knows the rules!
mackmanco1bite9/1/18, 6:27 p.m.
Minimal Brooklyn Flop. Good sauce to cheese ratio. Crispy. Piping Hot. One bite everybody knows the rules.