Brooklyn Pizza - Grill

One of Lancaster’s best! My top tree. Great people reside at Brooklyn

consistently always thin and crispy, good sauce. My fav pizza spot in the area We have 4 pizza places within 10 min of me and I’ll drive 20 min here

Sicilian pizza is good overall. Nice crisp and the cheese is pretty good. Sauce lacks a bit of flavor

7.4 is about right, solid pizza but nothing crazy

Sauce had good tang.

The crunch of the Sicilian crust was phenomenal. However, nothing too noteworthy regarding the cheese and sauce.

Wish there was more sauce, but OK pizza here. Decent crust, good mild sauce with OK cheese.

Good crust. Sauce and cheese are ok. Good for central PA.

Beautiful thin crust. Crispy, even the air bubbles were crispy. A little greasy and a little too much cheese, but really good slice.

One of the best in this area(of course it’s not New York) but a great pie.. I had to get each slice a bit crispier in my oven.. I recommend asking them for a well done pie with an occasional spin to get closer to perfection ( at least in this area) … Go Giants … Boo Eagles!!

Hands down the best pizzas in Lancaster County. Zero flop. Always takes fresh and sauce has a great tang. As close to NYC pizza you can get in the area. Has to be some Naples in the bloodline!

We got off to a bad start - this one didn’t want to be picked up. Overall very greasy - decent slice but I wouldnt travel for it. Go for the grandma slice - it was much better IMO

Good crisp, not much flop, good undercarriage. Cheese a little chewy but good pizza.

Burned my face off. Good pie little flop still nice crisp. Cheese was a little chewy. I’d eat it again.

Great traditional football pizza! Love the sauce.

New York style holds true - fresh, good crisp - alittle heavy on cheese/ grease but overall a great slice

It is a little on the greasy side but I really liked the taste. A little thicker than my optimal slice but it crunchy and right so I still thought it was good. Crust was really great. I would eat this again. Decent pie in Lancaster!

Probably the best slice in Lancaster. crispy crust. Thin slice. Not greasy. Good sauce to cheese ratio and the sauce is pretty good.

Slight flop and perfectly crisp crust. Cheese not too salty. Sauce just the right amount of flavor. Awesome slice!

Good slice. Sauce to cheese ratio needs work. Too much cheese Crust was crispy