If an 8 means “must travel“, this is not an 8. It’s good pizza. Good sharp on the undercarriage, but the crust is very basic. It’s well-made, but an 8 is overhyped. Grandma slice is good but under delivered on how good it looks 🎤
Order now on Slice
Order Brooklyn Pizza Masters
Hungry? Order right now on Slice
daveturner1/30/23, 12:54 a.m.
One block from where my son lives, tried a Margherita slice and vodka grandma slice (wifey had a white pizza slice … ricotta spinach artichoke) Basing my score on reheated slices. They use good quality ingredients but not worthy of 8s, slices were very good and I’d be very happy to have this pizza restaurant near me. But would not drive an hour for it, hence 7.9 Next time I visit my son, perhaps I’ll order a fresh whole cheese pizza and give it a accurate score.
rob.tulcin12/27/22, 12:24 a.m.
Very good overall. Had the vodka square & margherita slices. Pretty good flavor in the sauces on both. The vodka sauce on a pizza was a nice change up. Crust had a decent crisp. Could have had a little more. A little grease, but not much. Cheese was good, but nothing to rave about. Had a good experience & worth a revisit. Solid pizza
adammjensen12/19/22, 10:36 p.m.
Had a great crispness but flop, good melted cheese without it being all over the place. Scientific marvel. Crust tasted above average. However, not enough sauce to get you into the 8’s
3.8pizza9/12/22, 5:39 p.m.
Been back multiple times. My favorite slice in NYC so far. Excellent
rjdanks6/23/22, 5:21 p.m.
I thought this was a slice I could trust but then I get given a square slice. I’m appalled. Still a decent slice but the form factor brings its score way down
jtpizza3/11/22, 7:12 p.m.
While this pizza didn’t have the appearance it definitely had the taste. Great sauce, awesome crust, and are sizable slices. Part of NY’s finest.
pablocontreras10/9/21, 4:39 a.m.
By far, one of the BEST by the size pizza joints I’ve been to! Firm and crispy crust, cheese and sauce is simply PERFECTION!
jay.somma9/3/21, 7:18 p.m.
Got the classic grandma and the bianco with carmilized onions. Grandma Margherita was perfect, crust was crispy and buttery but thin enough not to be heavy at all, great sauce and cheese. 8.3 The regular style slice which was the carmilized onion slice was decent but to heavy for my liking, 6.7