Brooklyn Pizza

It was a good vibe in side and the owner seems to be a cool guy. The pizza was your basic pizza but still good.

Solid pie. Not too greasy, has a little flop, and the crust has a nice crunch. Would absolutely get this again.

Very good NY style pizza. Crust is crispy and tasty. Good proportion of cheese and sauce. Not too greasy like many area joints.

Just the cheese

Good slice, the pepperoni was a little greasy but the crust had crunch. The white pizza was great!

A little floppy. Good, crisp crust. Good flavor.

The moron who gave this a 4.8 is an asshat. It’s a good solid pie. Maybe the best in Columbus.

So greasy. Not good at all.

A good New York style pie with a nice crisp crust. The crust is flavorless but my dogs seemed to enjoy it 🤷‍♂️

Good quality, very tasty, would recommend it for NY style

I agree with my boys assessment.. good pizza, best option we have around.

Great NY slice. Balance of cheese, sauce, and crisp. Just fantastic.

Good solid pizza, if you live close eat it.

Best pizza in Columbus. Underrated must eat there

Ordered a large half pepperoni half cheese. Also got a slice for the car ride home. Sauce, cheese, and pepperoni all had great flavor. The individual slice was warmed and crust had fantastic crisp (would have given that slice an 8.1). Pie crust was less crispy, but also had less flop than expected. Maybe will ask for it be more crispy next time. Very nice pie and I felt good value compared to some other pizza in the area. I will be returning!

Pretty good pizza a greasy and cheese was falling off but pretty good still

I’m a fan. Good crust and good cheese. Can’t ask for much more

Best pizza around, criminally underrated. Closest thing to real NY pizza you're gonna get in Columbus, just look at it. Could use another minute in the oven to get that crisp but this should be the most popular pizza place around by a long shot.

A little heavy on the garlic aftertaste for me, but otherwise still a quality pie