kabong2/28/21, 12:45 a.m.
Great Pie. Love the sauce. You can really taste the fresh tomato’s. Just enough mootz and grated cheese. Thick and crispy. Drove over an hour and worth the ride. You want to order a whole pie and eat it there. Bravo Brooklyn Square
pizzadahutt12/23/20, 5:18 a.m.
Great pie. Quality ingredients. Thick yet somehow airy and crispy crust. Sauce is awesome.
pzza4life12/4/20, 12:37 a.m.
Solid upside down square- worth the trip if your nearby and not from the area. Will be back for sure.
gowanis.king8/29/20, 8:42 p.m.
Square style, very sauce heavy and bursting with flavor. Pillowy center with a good crispy undercarriage. Top notch non-traditional slice.
shaun.gaffney6/20/20, 6:04 p.m.
Already did the original, but stopped at this one on the way home from the shore. Best New Jersey pizza you can find.
neil.leone5/29/20, 9:00 p.m.
When you name your place ‘Brooklyn Square’ it is clearly a nod to L&B. Well, this ain’t L&B. Sauce is nice and the flavor does distinctly mirror L&B. Cheese and crust are nowhere close to the real Brooklyn square on 86th. If you are in the Freehold area, try Mateo’s - far better upside down pie. That’s a review.
frank.wahl4/29/20, 11:45 p.m.
Phenomenal square slice. I'll put this up against that other Brooklyn place any day of the week!
jrzanyc4/1/20, 10:40 p.m.
All right pizza review time, quarantine style. Trying to do hit and runs. Get in grab and run. Stayin corona free in the 2K 20. So I got the regular Dave official slice and they also got the Brooklyn Square. For obvious reasons. So I’m going to review my more favorite of the two which was the Brooklyn Square. A.k.a. the L&B slice. If you know anything about pizza you know they started this trend. I was very impressed with the square slice. Real nice tang on the sauce nice and sweet. A good crust on the bottom although I think he burnt my slice a little bit too much but I can see how it would’ve came out normally obviously mine was reheated. The dough was nice and airy in the middle the way I like it. Good quality cheese. I was very impressed. They probably would’ve got a better score had I got a better prepared and not reheated slice but it is what it is. So I’m going 8.6 for the square. I haven’t tried the Jackson location yet although I attempted to about a month ago and there was a two hour wait and you couldn’t even get in the door. I don’t know about you guys but I don’t got time like that. So bonus time. As for the standard slice. Pretty standard fare. Maybe a little upgraded. Interesting thing with the sesame seeds on the crust. I was apprehensive but I actually liked it. Needed a little more sauce and the cheese was pretty good quality. Again this slice was also a little overcooked when he reheated it. And that’s saying a lot because I order my pies well done. So if you put a gun to my head and asked me to review the regular slice probably 7.7. OK back in the house until next time quarantine style.
joe.carfagno2/29/20, 1:45 p.m.
Loved this place and apparently the Jackson location even better. I’m big on the upside down squares like this and these are so light and fluffy could crush half a pie easily.
lennoll12/26/20, 6:55 p.m.
Wow! Sweet sauce, fresh Muzz and liberally sprinkled Parmesan... all piled high on top of a perfectly crispy-bottomed pillow of dough. Deeee-Lish.
jariso132/23/20, 12:54 a.m.
Original square from Manalapan. Takeout. Dough was nice and fluffy. Good sauce tonight.
anthony.cammarata2/16/20, 9:33 p.m.
The upside down Square was worth the trip. Closest thing yet to the one and only L&B.
kevin.hayden11/10/19, 7:30 p.m.
One bite everyone knows the rules… OK Frankie, definitely and Interesting slice. The sesame seed crust while intriguing cost this score a point or two. I enjoyed it but I couldn’t eat probably more than 2 slices. Good cheese to sauce ratio, crust was a tad too doughy which made for a lot of flop. I liked the sauce flavor... more on the sweeter side. Had a fresh pie made just so i could give a proper review. Now that’s a review... 👍🏻