Crust on the square was hard as a rock but otherwise good, regular slice solid
Order now on Slice
Order Brooklyn Square Pizza
Hungry? Order right now on Slice
km0113/17/22, 12:13 p.m.
Not only did I drive over 6 hours for try this pizza (along with all the other NJ spots I went to), but my dumbass actually put the wrong Brooklyn square location in my GPS, which took us about 30 minutes out of the way! FML lol! The upside down from Brooklyn square is unlike anything else I've ever had, as it's extremely dense yet the pizza actually taste soft and pillowy but somehow still has an incredible crunch at the bottom. I also tried one of their standard cheese slices which I thought was very good as well and I actually like the sesame seeds on the crust as I have yet to see another place do that in all of my reviews! 8.2 on their standard cheese and 8.7 on the upside down!
ryan.rutherford2/22/22, 2:40 a.m.
🟥BEST SQUARE PIZZA ALERT🟥 Not only is this one of the best square pies I’ve ever had, it’s some of the best pizza New Jersey has to offer. First of all, the box weighs a ton; you would think the pizza was made with bricks. Each slice is a full meal, like eating a loaf of bread, very filling but incredibly delicious. The dough is heavy but also super fluffy, fresh and soft with a firm undercarriage and a delightfully tasty and crispy crust. Because this is an “Upside Down” style pie, the mozzarella hugs the dough while the sauce rests atop. The mozzarella cheese is extremely fresh and stringy, coating the dough beautifully, an ideal amount. The sauce is thick & hearty, plenty of spice and substance, with the sweetness neutralized by the Pecorino Romano cheese sprinkled across the top. This is an exquisite combination of flavors all working in conjunction, creating a perfect harmony of taste. When it comes to square pies, this is better than L&B Spumoni Gardens in Brooklyn, but just as heavy. Easily one of the best square slices in NJ, just a notch below Michael Angelo’s square pizza in Fairfield. I can’t speak for the other 2 Brooklyn Square locations, but this one is worth making a trip to whether you love square pies or not.
frankie.hesdra2/20/22, 10:12 p.m.
First time trying the vodka upside down slice. Gotta say I’m pretty impressed with the vodka sauce combined with the upside down slice
shawn.gilkison2/11/22, 5:43 p.m.
Square is excellent..regular pie is good 7.5. Try the vodka square also!
angelo.cutrone1/19/22, 8:07 p.m.
Amazing pepperoni Sicilian pie. Upside down… whatever. Delicious. Santillos like but fluffier.
jerseypies12/23/21, 10:11 p.m.
I’m not typically a fan of this style pizza but this was is by far the best of this style I’ve ever had. Again, not at all my cup of tea, but i would order a whole pie in a heart beat.
phillyg2311/26/21, 11:27 p.m.
Plain and Nonna pies were banging. Square was delicious but heavy
paulfrommontauk10/10/21, 2:56 p.m.
The Square pie is a sweet sauced upside down sicilian pizza for $25 plus change. Doesn’t compare to the rightside up sicilian at Joe’s Fleetwood in Mt Vernon NY
22 views•2 likes
michael.zanfardino9/16/21, 6:40 p.m.
I ordered the NJ Square and the Peter special. The NJ Square is a normal silician slice with pepperoni. It is fluffier and better than L&B. You can taste the pecorino and the pepperoni are a perfect add. My girlfriend dominated the Peter special. And Peter and his staff were nothing but nice. Talked for a few minutes, made me feel welcome. Amazing pizza. Would come back anytime
hyper9/14/21, 8:58 p.m.
Very good pizza but Dave rated too high. The sesame seeds on the crust was unique. 6.8 on the Sicilian.
tom.ruggia9/13/21, 12:00 p.m.
Excellent Sicilian pie. Love the “upside down” style. Crust was solid.
ken.schrader9/4/21, 8:01 p.m.
Upside down square - full pie, dine in: Light fluffy body, crispy crusted bottom, flavorful edge crust, tomato sauce has a delicious sweetness that compliments to hint of parma mixed in with the mozzarella. Peter the owner too time to chat with us and make sure everything was to our pleasure. Very nice guy! Can't wait to show this place off!!
big_lou_approved8/16/21, 4:20 p.m.
John Pepe - Check out this 🍕review and more on my Instagram @big_lou_approved
61 views•7 likes