A really good all around pizza. Fluffy crust in the middle, crisp but not burn on the outside of the crust. The sauce is excellent and not too overpowering.
mrmcsisterfister5/7/21, 12:48 a.m.
Cheese and sauce are amazing. Crust and undercarriage is pretty good too. Definitely the best Sicilian pizza I’ve ever had, well worth the 30 minute drive
pizzaking19775/1/21, 10:36 a.m.
Sauce was great, center was light and fluffy, crust was alittle burnt but overall really good! We also tried there plain cheese pie with pepperoni, really liked that with the sesame seeds on the crust and the pepperoni cupped!
lennoll14/21/21, 11:38 p.m.
Figured I’d try the Nonna Square since I rated the Brooklyn an 8.8 at their Manalapan location. Good... but big step down.
robert.andrew14/3/21, 9:24 p.m.
Bad picture, awesome pie. Classic L&B style Sicilian square pie, but way way better than what I’ve had in Brooklyn in a very very long time... Gotta be this location though, not crazy about the Toms River location.
pizzaman954/3/21, 12:22 a.m.
Very good slice. Sesame seeds add a nice touch. Overall best pizza in ocean county. The square pie (rated it multiple times) was outstanding as always.
big_lou_approved3/28/21, 5:33 p.m.
I talk about this place all of time. It’s incredible. If you haven’t had Brooklyn Square you better get your ass to one of their 3 locations. There’s nothing else I need to say 🍕
15 views•0 likes
jim.harris33/17/21, 5:02 a.m.
If you're a Sicilian guy, this is the pizza for you. The Upside Down is the one you want. A great chewiness to the crust, great cheese. The sauce does dominate the flavor a bit.
chris.jf073/14/21, 9:53 p.m.
I’ve had the Upside Down Square Pizza many times now and it never disappoints. The taste of the pizza is unbelievable. Also, the crust is as good and flavorful as it gets. It’s definitely the best square style pizza I’ve ever had.
sds52193/7/21, 6:23 p.m.
Crust was crispy on the bottom and fluffy in the middle, although it was slightly burnt. Quality sauce and cheese.
mike.smithh3/6/21, 4:16 p.m.
Best Sicilian square pizza in Jersey. The cheese is so fresh and thick that it melts in your mouth with the dough. The crust is not too cooked but not undercooked either. tomato sauce has the right amount of tang to it. simply, amazing pizza
slicknick352/20/21, 7:16 p.m.
Silcian is really tasty.regular slice has no flop and has sesame seed on the crust
jason.borrelli2/16/21, 3:25 a.m.
This pizza was phenomenal. If you are looking for a Sicilian but don’t want to eat a brick this is your pie. It’s as light as a feather and great flavor. My son and I visited after his youth hockey game. Peter the owner was so hospitable accommodating us by opening a few minutes earlier than 11am.
manny.gomes2/16/21, 2:06 a.m.
Solid pizza. Definitely what they're known for. Sauce had a good tang. Cheese didn't slide off. Crust was fluffy yet crispy. Solid 8.3. Not my type of pizza but solid nonetheless. Also, wasn't crazy about the grated cheese.
cent1742/14/21, 9:53 p.m.
If your looking for a normal tasting boring slice don’t go here. This is a unique upside down Sicilian type of pie. Unique tasting crunchy crust and under carriage. The sauce very tasty and full of flavor. I think Dave’s review was spot on. Only knock was the inconsistency for the entire pie- 1-2 slices had barely any cheese, not that it wasn’t good, but the other slices were incredible. Highly recommend!
jim.car2/2/21, 12:06 a.m.
Got the original “Brooklyn Square” pizza. Dave, my man... are you getting soft??? This pizza absolutely sucked! Sauce had this weird sweet aftertaste and the dough was VERY heavy!!! Not at all as Dave talked about being “light and airy”!!! One of the worst pizzas I have ever had.