This pizza was phenomenal. If you are looking for a Sicilian but don’t want to eat a brick this is your pie. It’s as light as a feather and great flavor. My son and I visited after his youth hockey game. Peter the owner was so hospitable accommodating us by opening a few minutes earlier than 11am.
cent1742/14/21, 9:53 p.m.
If your looking for a normal tasting boring slice don’t go here. This is a unique upside down Sicilian type of pie. Unique tasting crunchy crust and under carriage. The sauce very tasty and full of flavor. I think Dave’s review was spot on. Only knock was the inconsistency for the entire pie- 1-2 slices had barely any cheese, not that it wasn’t good, but the other slices were incredible. Highly recommend!
jim.car2/2/21, 12:06 a.m.
Got the original “Brooklyn Square” pizza. Dave, my man... are you getting soft??? This pizza absolutely sucked! Sauce had this weird sweet aftertaste and the dough was VERY heavy!!! Not at all as Dave talked about being “light and airy”!!! One of the worst pizzas I have ever had.
ben.cohen101/21/21, 7:23 p.m.
sauce is awesome dough is cripsy yet like a pillow overall creat slice
metro12/26/20, 4:30 p.m.
Cheese, sauce, crust ratio on this one was off. Too much cheese. It looked like there were 2 layers of sliced Mozzarella under the sauce, then another layer of tangy cheese on top of the sauce in spots. Too much cheese. If the third tangy cheese was gone, this would be in the 8’s.
johnny.warhawks12/25/20, 11:18 p.m.
Amazing pizza! The best grandma pie by far. The sauce is very tasteful and the dough is the softest I’ve had.
robertm15912/23/20, 10:11 p.m.
Pizza was thick and fluffy. Not generally a big sauce guy but this pizza was an ocean of saucy goodness. Cheese was perfectly melted but still felt like I wanted more. Pizza is great and will definitely be back
nick.librera12/5/20, 11:02 p.m.
Brooklyn square was a dough fest! Grease? Yes. Overrated? Most definitely! Dave, I'm coming for you, because if this is better than L&B, you’re crazy. Take your wack ass taste buds back to New England.
mh4239812/2/20, 7:45 p.m.
Holy cow this pizza effs. Delicious sauce and quality cheese. Awesome light dough for a square slice
nick.usa.9912/1/20, 6:41 p.m.
Honestly one of the best in NJ, don’t see how dave get dilorenzos a 9.2 i think this place is slightly better , both being respectfully great.
itsjustjohn1311/27/20, 8:39 p.m.
Overall solid slice, good sauce to cheese ratio and tasty sauce. I do prefer sauce under the cheese though.
rms1711/19/20, 5:48 p.m.
Not my favorite style but had to get in on it. Really good. Heavy but the crust is airy and light. Great cheese and sauce is just sweet enough.
areustunad11/10/20, 3:46 p.m.
So good. Crunchy bottom, fluffy middle, sauce and cheese taste amazing. Love the normal style sesame crust too. Great pizza.
robert.owenburg10/30/20, 10:12 p.m.
Awesome tangy sauce and perfect ratio of cheese underneath. Fluffy crust is cooked very well. Best local Sicilian style pizza for sure.