About Brooklyn Square Pizza
331 Yelp Reviews
phillyg2311/26/21, 11:27 p.m.
Plain and Nonna pies were banging. Square was delicious but heavy
paulfrommontauk10/10/21, 2:56 p.m.
The Square pie is a sweet sauced upside down sicilian pizza for $25 plus change. Doesn’t compare to the rightside up sicilian at Joe’s Fleetwood in Mt Vernon NY
14 views•1 like
michael.zanfardino9/16/21, 6:40 p.m.
I ordered the NJ Square and the Peter special. The NJ Square is a normal silician slice with pepperoni. It is fluffier and better than L&B. You can taste the pecorino and the pepperoni are a perfect add. My girlfriend dominated the Peter special. And Peter and his staff were nothing but nice. Talked for a few minutes, made me feel welcome. Amazing pizza. Would come back anytime
h.per9/14/21, 8:58 p.m.
Very good pizza but Dave rated too high. The sesame seeds on the crust was unique. 6.8 on the Sicilian.
tom.ruggia9/13/21, 12:00 p.m.
Excellent Sicilian pie. Love the “upside down” style. Crust was solid.
ken.schrader9/4/21, 8:01 p.m.
Upside down square - full pie, dine in: Light fluffy body, crispy crusted bottom, flavorful edge crust, tomato sauce has a delicious sweetness that compliments to hint of parma mixed in with the mozzarella. Peter the owner too time to chat with us and make sure everything was to our pleasure. Very nice guy! Can't wait to show this place off!!
state088/30/21, 2:52 a.m.
Crust on the square was hard as a rock but otherwise good, regular slice solid
big_lou_approved8/16/21, 4:20 p.m.
John Pepe - Check out this 🍕review and more on my Instagram @big_lou_approved
48 views•7 likes
mrssugewhite8/8/21, 8:26 p.m.
I love these Pizza reviews, however, Dave likes pizza with ZERO FLAVOR. I keep trying his highest reviewed pizza, and left miserably disappointed. I appreciate ALL HIS reviews, and I will keep venturing out until we agree on one. From the algorithm I can tell.... He is more about texture and I am more about flavor. I can't wait for us to find the perfect serendipitous pie.
l david.grover7/28/21, 1:47 a.m.
First time there was phenomenal and rated very high. Back in town and stopped in. Staff super nice but this time pizza was raw . Also never had a pizza that was so sweet that it could pass a a desert. Very disappointed
chris.pistorio7/23/21, 4:31 p.m.
Hell of a pizza and even better owner. Owner was a very nice guy.
dsmith13187/18/21, 11:34 p.m.
Not my normal style, but solid non the less. Love what they did with it.
bmk1817/12/21, 10:58 p.m.
Cheese has great flavor the sauce has subtle sweetness I really enjoyed. The crust is definitely what makes the pizza and is what separates this place from any other. I would drive 3 hrs for this pizza buy fortunately I only have to drive 1. Second favorite pizza of all time.
brandon.lane47/2/21, 10:15 p.m.
Sauce was excellent and very sweet which I like. Could have been cooked more but one of the best square pizzas I have ever had. Highly recommend it!
dylan_lane7/2/21, 10:11 p.m.
Great taste, more doughy then I’d like however they were very busy and i can cut them some slack